You paid the going price for the stock and never asked if the number made sense on its own. Then the market changed its mind, and the price dropped. Connie Pickering calls herself one of the lucky ones in Pheasant Ridge, a mobile home community in Manor Township, Pennsylvania. She’s 66 and lives there with her husband and her mother, who is 89. People in Pheasant Ridge own their homes and rent the ground under them, and the monthly lot fee has been going up. Hers was $900 when she talked to the paper, and her family could still pay it. A lot of her neighbors are retired or living on low incomes, and some of them, she told LNP’s Lancaster Watchdog in July, are barely getting by.
That’s why she reached out to the paper. In June the county mailed out new assessments, its first reassessment in nine years, and the notices were the talk of Pheasant Ridge. The assessed value of her mobile home went up 141 percent. She said some of her neighbors’ assessments went up more than the township as a whole, too. The county’s own table puts the township’s median increase at 80.99 percent.
She grew up in a mobile home community, and she’d always understood that a mobile home doesn’t gain value the way a house on a foundation does. A legal aid lawyer told the paper the same thing. A mobile home that isn’t on a permanent foundation gets its title from the state’s transportation department, like a car. And like a car, it’s worth nothing once it’s used up. In a community like hers, the landowner pays the tax on the land and each resident pays the tax on the home. So the new number landed on her home, and that’s the part Pickering pays tax on.
In June, the paper explained where that number came from. County assessors build values from recent sales of similar properties nearby. And the Watchdog found that recent sales in Pheasant Ridge include several homes bought for more than $100,000. Richard Boas Jr., a real estate agent on the county’s appeals board, said a mobile home gets judged by the same test as any other property: could you sell it at that price?
Randy Blough is a retired scientist who helped start a legal aid program in neighboring Chester County for mobile home owners who appeal their assessments. He told the paper that’s not the whole story. The assessment puts all real estate in one class, so the formula assumes the mobile home went up in value when it’s really been losing value.
Valuation models can have the same problem: the answer comes from the same prices you’re trying to judge. I go looking for it. When a model projects a company’s cash years ahead, most of the answer comes from one number at the very end. You multiply the last year’s cash by it, and it stands in for all the years after the forecast stops.
The usual way is to pick today’s price-to-free-cash-flow ratio. Free cash flow is the cash a company has left after paying for everything the business needed. Divide the price by it, and you get what the market pays right now for each dollar of that cash. It’s the company’s own number, and you can look it up in a second. It’s also circular, because the first number in that ratio is the price.
So when you use today’s ratio as the number at the end, you take today’s price, run it through the model, and compare the result with today’s price. You’re asking the market whether it agrees with itself. Let’s say two companies have the same cash, the same growth and the same debt. One trades at 40 times its free cash flow, and the other trades at 12. Give each one its own ratio from today, and the expensive one comes out worth more. You just handed it a bigger number to work with.
And it’s worst with the stocks that just made a big move. A stock that has run up has a high ratio, so the number at the end is high and the stock scores well. One that’s been beaten down gets the opposite. The method makes whatever has already gone up look good. It’s what Blough described: the formula assumes a mobile home went up because the ones around it sold for more.
What I use instead
I use the median of the company’s own price-to-free-cash-flow over a long stretch, long enough to cover a full cycle. The median is the middle value when you line up all those years, so a single week’s price is just one reading among many. Let’s say a company traded at 90 times its cash in one bubble year. It shouldn’t carry that number into every valuation after that. Do the same with Pheasant Ridge, and those sales above $100,000 would be a few readings among the ordinary years around them.
This measures something smaller than what the company is worth. It tells you what the market has usually paid for a dollar of this company’s cash in ordinary years. And that doesn’t move when the price jumps around for a week.
You can’t judge today’s price with anything that has today’s price in it. Would your answer change if the stock jumped 30 percent overnight and nothing happened to the business? If it would, the price is inside your model, and it doesn’t belong there.
Where this breaks
It breaks when a company deserves to be valued higher than it used to be. Think of a business that went from selling hardware every few years to selling software every month. It earned its higher number. The long median, the same kind I use for growth, drags the old, lower number along for years, and the company keeps scoring badly the whole time. It cuts the other way too. The median is still made of prices, just a lot more of them, so the loop gets looser but doesn’t go away. If the market overpaid for a company for a decade, that decade stays in the median.
It also needs years of history, and a company that listed recently doesn’t have them. That leaves out the newer companies people argue about most. And when a company reports in one currency and its shares trade in another, the ratio mixes two currencies. For a long time, a fixed, cautious number went in its place. On September 11 I measured that fixed number, and for a lot of companies it wasn’t the cautious choice. It scored them higher than their own ratio did. I fixed the currency problem the same day. Now each year’s price gets converted at that year’s exchange rate, so most of those companies get a ratio of their own. The fixed number stays only where there isn’t enough history, and then I use the lower of the two.
Where Connie Pickering’s number came from
Pickering told the paper she’d been in touch with the assessment office and would most likely appeal. The deadline was August 3. A friend who’s a real estate agent was helping her hire an appraiser, which runs $300 to $500. “I’m going to do it. I’m going to have to do it,” she said.
The county posted its answers to the questions it expected people to ask, and the one about homes is on page three. The county took the valid sales from 2022 through 2024, neighborhood by neighborhood, and used them to estimate the value of the properties around them. Her home’s size and what’s on it get a value too, and then that value is adjusted to what sold nearby. So her 2027 tax bill will be based on what her neighbors’ homes sold for between 2022 and 2024. The usual model works the same way: the number at the end comes from the company’s own price.
The guide the county mailed with the notices tells her what to ask herself before she appeals: could she sell the home for the new value in today’s market? By August, owners had appealed on 2 percent of the county’s taxable properties. The county’s assessment director said so at a meeting of the appeals board, the paper reported. Each hearing lasts five to fifteen minutes.
Key factsThe numbers and where they come from · 5 September 2026
- In June 2026, Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, mailed out its first new assessments in nine years. The county’s table puts the median increase in Manor Township at 80.99 percent.
- The assessed value of Connie Pickering’s mobile home in Pheasant Ridge went up 141 percent, she told LNP’s Lancaster Watchdog in July 2026.
- According to the county’s reassessment FAQ, assessors used valid sales from 2022 through 2024, neighborhood by neighborhood, to estimate the value of the properties around them.
- Owners of 2 percent of the county’s taxable properties had appealed by August 2026, the county’s assessment director told the appeals board, LNP reported.
