A thin margin looks like a business barely getting by, so you walk away. Years later it’s still going. Tony Barzar has been ringing up Costco members in Tucson for most of the past forty years. He’s sixty. The Wall Street Journal followed him through a shift. He was working the self-checkout area, six registers, and the first shoppers were ready to pay just after nine.
He started in 1986, pushing carts in a Tucson parking lot for $5.85 an hour. When the Journal followed him, he was making $32.90, the top of Costco’s hourly scale. His wife used to work in the bakery, and when she was diagnosed with brain cancer, the company’s health plan covered her three brain surgeries. The Journal reports he has more than a million dollars in his retirement account. “This is my calling,” he told the paper.
Costco’s executives told the Journal that workers like Barzar are the company’s secret weapon: they’re reliable, they keep a line moving, and they teach the new hires how the place works.
The company’s own annual report puts a figure on how long people stay. In the United States and Canada, about 94 percent of the employees who had been there at least a year were still there at the end of fiscal 2025. It also says pay and benefits are the company’s biggest expense after the goods themselves. And after paying all of that, Costco keeps about three cents of every dollar it sells.
In Costco’s fiscal year that ended in August 2025, that came to a net margin of 2.9 percent, the profit left from each dollar of sales. Seven years earlier, in fiscal 2018, it was 2.2 percent. Three cents on the dollar sounds like a business one bad year away from keeping nothing. And Costco has paid Barzar through every one of those years.
The margin only tells you what each dollar of sales leaves behind. It says nothing about how many dollars had to sit inside the company to make those sales happen. For a retailer, that’s the big question. At Costco the answer is on the shelves Barzar scans all day.
Where the money isn’t
At the end of that same fiscal year, the goods in Costco’s warehouses were worth $18,116 million, and Costco owed the suppliers who delivered them $19,783 million. The report says it plainly: Costco often sells its goods before it has to pay for them. By the time a supplier’s bill comes due, Barzar has already rung the goods up and the members have already paid. The suppliers are paying for what’s on the shelves. The members chip in too. Costco was holding more than $2.8 billion in membership fees for months it hadn’t delivered yet.
That’s how the margin can be thin while the return isn’t. Return on capital answers one question: for every dollar tied up in the business, how much profit does it make in a year? There are several ways to define “tied up,” and I’ll use the plainest one so you can check it. Take the shareholders’ own money in the company, add the long-term borrowing and subtract the cash sitting idle, and you get $20,716 million of capital in the business. The stores earned about $7,777 million after tax. Divide $7,777 million by $20,716 million and you get about 37.5 percent. For every dollar tied up, Costco makes thirty-seven cents a year. The same math on the fiscal 2018 report gives about 24 percent. So the margin went from 2.2 to 2.9 percent, which looks like the same business doing a little better. But the return on capital went from 24 to 37, and that means something changed.
Let’s say you’ve got two grocers that both keep three cents on the dollar. One uses the same dollar of its own money many times a year, because its suppliers wait and its customers pay up front. The other has to pay for its goods with its own cash and gets two uses out of that dollar in a year. People quote the three cents. Whether a grocer can keep a cashier at the top of the scale for forty years depends on what it earns on the money it has to keep inside the business.
Where this breaks
That’s the textbook way to do the math, and it isn’t the only one. I took the cash out of the base, because cash sitting in a bank account isn’t doing any work. But you can argue a good part of that cash is there because Costco sold goods it hadn’t paid for yet, so it belongs in. Leave the $14,161 million of cash in, and the base grows to $34,877 million. The same $7,777 million of profit on that base comes to about 22 percent. Add what Costco owes on the land and buildings it rents, and the return shrinks again. And this return depends on the suppliers being willing to wait for their money. In that report they still were, and my guess is that being on Costco’s shelves is worth the terms to them. If Costco had to pay for the goods with its own money, the $18,116 million of inventory would go on top of the $20,716 million base, for $38,832 million in all. The same profit on that comes to about 20 percent, and the margin wouldn’t move at all. So some of that 37 percent comes from the suppliers’ terms, and I’d want to know how much. Builders FirstSource showed what that looks like from the other side: cash that comes from not yet paying suppliers tends to go back out when the bills come due.
The return on capital tells you what kind of business you’ve got. What you make owning a piece of it depends on what you pay for that piece, and I don’t get into the price here. And I’ve only shown one year, which is enough to see how it works. A company can post a great return the year it happens to hold little inventory and an ordinary one the year after. You have to look at several years to tell whether a high return comes from the business or from one good year.
Barzar’s registers
In fiscal 2025 the suppliers were carrying every dollar on the shelves Barzar scans, and $1,667 million on top of it. That 2018 report shows $11,040 million of goods and $11,237 million owed to suppliers, a gap of $197 million. From $197 million to $1,667 million, the gap got about $1.5 billion wider, against a base of about $20.7 billion. Costco’s report has a name for that gap, “net investment in merchandise inventories”, and it lists “payment terms with suppliers” among the things that move it.
If I had Costco in my portfolio, I’d open each annual report and put merchandise inventories next to accounts payable. If payables are still the bigger number, the suppliers are still carrying the shelves. Then I’d work out the return on capital the plain way I did here, for several years in a row.
I left Costco’s price out of this article. To see whether Costco looks cheap or expensive today, look it up in Bufetico.
You’ll still see a margin like Costco’s and think the business is barely getting by. Find out who’s paying for the shelves before you walk away.
Key factsThe numbers and where they come from · 15 September 2026
- In fiscal 2025, the year that ended in August 2025, Costco’s net margin was 2.9 percent, up from 2.2 percent in fiscal 2018 (Costco’s annual report).
- Costco’s warehouses held goods worth $18,116 million at the end of fiscal 2025, and it owed the suppliers who delivered them $19,783 million. The annual report says Costco often sells its goods before it has to pay for them.
- At the end of fiscal 2025, Costco was holding more than $2.8 billion in membership fees for months it had not yet delivered, the annual report shows.
- Costco’s fiscal 2018 report shows $11,040 million of goods and $11,237 million owed to suppliers. The company calls the difference its net investment in merchandise inventories and lists payment terms with suppliers among the things that move it.
