A debt number scared you away from a company, or it calmed you down about one. Either way, it was telling you the wrong thing. Elyse Burns was in law school at Duke when she figured out she wasn’t going to be a lawyer. She’d taken out federal loans for the tuition and her living costs, and she finished the degree anyway. She never took the bar.
By then she already had a business, one she’d been running since she was a teenager. It started with hand-painted canvases. She opened a bank account on her eighteenth birthday, linked it to an Etsy seller account, and sold two pieces within a week.
It was still a side hustle when she started law school. She says it really picked up once she started posting her work on TikTok and selling her designs wholesale to stores through Faire.
“I feel like everybody knows you can make a good living as a lawyer, and you can’t as an artist,” she told CNBC in June 2026. Once the art paid enough to live on, she started having second thoughts about being a lawyer.
She’d thought about two ways to pay off the loans. She could take a corporate law job with a big salary and clear them fast, or she could do ten years of public interest law and then have the rest forgiven. Neither one appealed to her. The man who’s now her husband trusted her to pay the loans off, and he backed her when she went after the career she cared about more.
When she graduated, the loans were still on the pandemic pause, with no interest building up. She wanted them gone before the interest started. By the next September she’d paid off all of it, more than $75,000, according to documents CNBC reviewed. And the money came from stickers and coloring books.
Her designs are sold in Blick art stores and in some Hallmark shops, and she has her own stationery store in Durham, North Carolina. She says some days she’s so tired she’d like someone else to take the company off her hands. But she doesn’t think that’s how she really feels.
The company, Elyse Breanne Design, is all hers, and she says she’s put its profits back into it all along. When a business keeps its profit, its equity grows. Equity is everything a business owns minus everything it owes. It’s the part that belongs to the owners.
Etsy, where she sold those first two pieces, went the other way. On paper, Etsy owes more than it owns. At the end of June, Etsy’s balance sheet showed shareholders’ equity of minus $1,395 million. It also showed just under $3 billion of debt, all of it notes, which are IOUs that Etsy sold to investors.
What the debt layer does with a minus sign
In my screener, every company gets six layers. Each one measures one thing and shows up as a colored square. Three of them, debt, profit and cash, tell you if a company is financially stable. The debt layer compares a company’s debt with its equity. A low ratio is comfortable, and a high one isn’t. But when equity is negative, you’re dividing by a negative number, and the ratio comes out below zero. On that scale, a company with debt looks safer than one that owes nothing at all. A ratio only works inside a certain range. This one stops working the moment equity drops below zero, and the math doesn’t warn you when it does.
So Etsy’s debt square stays gray. Usually gray means a number is missing, but Etsy publishes both numbers, its debt and its equity. Here, gray means the ratio can’t be read while equity is below zero. And Etsy still owes the notes.
How Etsy got below zero
Two things put it there. In 2022, Etsy wrote off about $1 billion of what it had paid for Depop and Elo7, two marketplaces it bought the year before. Writing it off means Etsy admitted on its books that they were worth less than it paid. In that one quarter, its equity went from positive to negative.
And every year since then, Etsy has spent more buying back its own stock than it made in profit. In 2025 it spent $777 million on buybacks and made $163 million of profit. Etsy cancels the shares it buys back, so that money comes straight out of equity. In July 2026 it sold Depop to eBay, and it said the cash would help it buy back shares faster. In August it approved up to $2 billion more for buybacks.
But buybacks don’t touch the debt. Etsy can keep buying back shares for years, and it still has to pay its notes in full, on the dates written in them. So I put the debt next to the cash the business makes.
Etsy’s free cash flow came to $610 million in the twelve months through June 2026. Free cash flow is the money left after Etsy pays its bills and pays for its equipment and software. That money, plus what’s already in the bank, is what pays the notes, unless Etsy borrows again to pay them.
Where this breaks
A company that’s borrowed too much and happens to have negative equity gets the same gray square as Etsy. The square can’t tell the two apart, and it doesn’t try to guess. If you read gray as nothing to see, you’ll walk right past the company with a real problem. I could swap in another ratio whenever equity goes negative, but that would be worse. Two companies would get their colors from two different calculations, and the same color would mean two different things.
Etsy’s own plan counts on borrowing again. It aims to keep its debt at about three times what it earns in a year, by its own adjusted measure. It also says it keeps enough cash on hand to cover the debt coming due in the next year and a half to two years. That way it can wait for a good moment to refinance, which means borrowing new money to pay off the old. The cash above all that goes to buybacks.
The date on Elyse Burns’s loans
Etsy’s oldest notes cost it 0.3 percent a year, counting the fees. There’s $649.9 million of them, and they were due on October 1, 2026. The notes it sold in June 2025 cost 1.3 percent, about four times as much.
Key factsThe numbers and where they come from · 8 September 2026
- At the end of June 2026, Etsy’s shareholders’ equity was minus $1,395 million, and it had just under $3 billion of debt, all of it notes sold to investors (Etsy’s quarterly report).
- In 2025, Etsy reported $163 million of profit and spent $777 million buying back its own stock. It cancels the shares it buys back, so that money comes straight out of equity.
- Etsy’s free cash flow came to $610 million over the twelve months through June 2026.
- Etsy’s oldest notes, $649.9 million, cost it 0.3 percent a year counting fees and were due in October 2026. The notes it sold in June 2025 cost 1.3 percent.
