You watched a company’s profit climb year after year, so you bought it. You never checked if the cash was climbing too. Tim Johns is the director of operations at Simpson Strong-Tie in Gallatin, Tennessee. He told the local paper the company ran out of room there, and it didn’t want to leave town. Learning to make nails and fasteners takes time, and the people who knew how were already in Gallatin.
So the company built a bigger plant on Airport Road. It opened on January 15, 2026, with a ribbon cutting and tours, the Gallatin News reported. It’s a $125 million plant with 227 employees: machine operators, maintenance technicians, heat treat technicians and engineers. The mayor, Paige Brown, said the company had been providing good jobs in Gallatin for more than 60 years. Johns told the paper: “Because of that, we wanted to keep our people. We didn’t want to move out of the area.”
Simpson Strong-Tie is the name on the plant. The company that files its reports with the SEC is Simpson Manufacturing. It sells the steel pieces that hold wooden houses together: connectors, fasteners and anchors. On September 11, 2026, I used it as my example of a company whose profit rose eleven years out of twelve while its cash fell twice. I didn’t name it, and I said I hadn’t gone through the lines that explain the gap. I’ve gone through them now.
Profit up eleven years, cash down twice
From 2014 to 2025, the company’s net income, its profit after everything, went up in eleven years out of twelve. It grew from $63.5 million to $345.1 million, with one step back: a drop of nine percent in 2024. Cash from operations, the cash the business brought in, doesn’t look like that. It fell by more than a fifth twice: in 2021, from $207.6 million to $151.3 million, and in 2024, from $427.0 million to $338.2 million. The 2021 drop came in a year when profit went up. The 2024 drop came in a year when profit was down only nine percent.
If you read only the profit line, you’d file this company as a steady grower with no ups and downs. The cash line says something hit it twice. Both lines come out of the same audited books, so the difference has to be sitting somewhere on the balance sheet, the page that lists what the company owns and what it owes.
2021, when the profit turned into steel
In 2021 Simpson reported $266.4 million of net income. Part of that never showed up as cash, and the cash flow statement says where it went. Inventory, the goods and materials sitting on its shelves, went from $283.7 million at the end of 2020 to $443.8 million a year later. That’s up 56 percent, in a year when sales grew 24 percent.
The annual report for that year describes what was on those shelves. It says that since December 2020, the pounds of inventory in North America went down 2 percent. That’s where most of it sits. But the average cost per pound of everything it held went up about 63 percent.
The company held a little less steel, and it was paying a lot more for each pound. The people in Gallatin make fasteners out of steel, and in 2021 the steel on hand cost far more than the year before. Customers paid the new prices, and a big part of that profit went right back into steel waiting to be made into nails and screws.
The swings in Simpson’s cash came from the price of steel, while demand for the product held up. Cash tied up in steel for a year is a matter of timing, and it came back the next year. And one year of this company’s cash, on its own, tells you very little.
The 2024 dip worked the same way, only smaller. That year cash from operations dropped by $88.9 million, and $50.4 million went back into inventory.
2026, running backward
The first half of 2026 shows the other side. Net income for the first six months was $215.3 million, and cash from operations was $248.5 million. This time the cash ran well ahead of the profit. And it’s the inventory line again, going the other way: down from $594.2 million in December to $513.5 million in June.
The half-year filing says steel costs held steady into early 2025, started rising late that year and kept rising through the second quarter of 2026. So the inventory dropped in dollars while each pound got more expensive. That means the pounds on the shelves dropped even faster than the dollars. In 2021 the profit went into the warehouse, and in 2026 it’s coming back out. The same filing names the Gallatin plant as the one bringing more of its fastener and anchor production in house, heat treating included.
What I do with a company like this
I don’t value a company like this on any single year, least of all the most recent one. When the price of what a business buys keeps moving, more often than not, the latest year is the odd one out. So I put the cash from operations over the whole stretch, the two bad years included, next to the profit line, and I look at the distance between them. Here the distance is wide, and the balance sheet explains it. How I turn the whole stretch into one figure is a topic for another article.
The margin is a separate story. Operating margin is what’s left from each dollar of sales after the costs of running the business. In the last two ordinary years before the housing boom, 2018 and 2019, it was 16.0 and 15.9 cents on the dollar. In 2021, with higher steel prices flowing into sales, it was 23.3. If the bad year you picture for Simpson still has a better margin than 2018 and 2019, you haven’t really pictured a bad year. The two cash dips landed in years with good margins, 23.3 in 2021, so the steel cycle and the margin are two different things to look at.
Where this breaks
I’ve told a story about steel from three lines of a cash flow statement and one sentence of an annual report. It fits, but a story that fits still isn’t proof.
Simpson also changed shape in 2022, when it bought Etanco, a European business. Any comparison across that year compares two different businesses that share a name. And for a company that sells into home building, twelve years of growth also means twelve years without a housing slump. What I’ve described is a cycle in the price of steel. The cycle that matters more is how many houses get built, and it barely shows up in this data. The filing says housing starts, the number of new homes builders begin, have been slipping since 2021. But a real housing slump, the kind that cuts a builder’s volume in half, isn’t in these twelve years. And the inventory coming off the shelves in 2026 could be good discipline. Or it could be the company running its shelves down as demand gets softer. These lines don’t say which.
The anchors and fasteners Gallatin makes
The new plant makes anchors, fasteners and the tools that drive them. The half-year filing says the company raised prices on some products in the United States twice in 2025, on June 2 and again on October 15, because of tariffs. Fasteners and anchors were among them. The filing credits those price increases for North America’s sales growth in recent quarters, and it says demand didn’t go up. For the first six months of 2026, the filing also lists higher volumes, meaning the company shipped more. The same filing says U.S. housing starts have gone down every year since 2021. It also says the company cut jobs in 2025 as part of a plan to save costs, which it started because housing starts were falling. It doesn’t say where. Gallatin’s plant opened in January 2026 with 227 people.
If I owned Simpson, I’d read each quarterly report with the inventory line next to cash from operations, to see whether the shelves are still giving cash back. Then I’d read what the filing says about prices and volumes, and work out how much of the sales growth comes from price increases and how much from shipping more.
To see whether Simpson Manufacturing looks cheap or expensive today, look it up in Bufetico.
Every quarterly report that shows Simpson’s profit also shows its cash from operations, so you can see if the cash is climbing too.
Key factsThe numbers and where they come from · 14 September 2026
- From 2014 to 2025, Simpson Manufacturing’s net income rose in eleven of twelve years, from $63.5 million to $345.1 million, according to the company’s annual reports.
- Simpson’s cash from operations fell by more than a fifth twice: in 2021, from $207.6 million to $151.3 million, and in 2024, from $427.0 million to $338.2 million (Simpson’s cash flow statements).
- In 2021, Simpson’s inventory went from $283.7 million to $443.8 million, up 56 percent in a year when sales grew 24 percent. That year’s annual report says the average cost per pound of inventory rose about 63 percent.
- In the first six months of 2026, Simpson’s net income was $215.3 million and its cash from operations was $248.5 million, while inventory fell from $594.2 million in December to $513.5 million in June (Simpson’s half-year filing).
