Bufetico Join the waitlist
The basicsCase study

Fine numbers, then the news hit: stock screener limitations, UnitedHealth, and a cancer writer in Miami

Charlotte Libov, 76, was being treated for cancer in a clinical trial in Miami in the summer of 2026, and UHealth says its contract with her Medicare plan, owned by UnitedHealth, ends on January 1, 2027. Stock screener limitations, seen through UnitedHealth's medical care ratio: what the numbers caught, and when.
9 October 2026 · · 5 min read

You did your homework, and the numbers looked fine. The bad news got to you before any of them moved. For more than 25 years, Charlotte Libov has written about cancer, and she’s told patients to get treated, if they can, at the big cancer centers that run the research and the clinical trials. In the summer of 2026, it looked like she might not be able to follow her own advice.

Libov is 76, lives in Miami Beach, and has breast cancer. She told the Miami Herald she was being treated in a clinical trial at Sylvester Comprehensive Cancer Center, which is part of UHealth, the University of Miami’s health system.

Her plan is a Medicare Advantage plan, the kind where a private insurer runs your Medicare. It comes from Preferred Care Network, which UnitedHealth owns. In July, UHealth and United, UnitedHealth’s insurance arm, were fighting over how much United pays UHealth’s doctors. UHealth said United wouldn’t pay enough. United said UHealth wanted too much. The Herald reported on July 28 that for patients in Libov’s plan, UHealth’s doctors could go out of network, meaning the plan would no longer have a contract with them, as early as September 1.

She told the Herald she hadn’t slept well since she found out. She said her treatment was part of a trial, so it wasn’t a standard treatment she could get at another hospital in South Florida. “This is kind of my worst nightmare,” she said. University of Miami students on a United plan were expected to stay in network either way, and that gave her some hope the two sides would make a deal.

Libov said that when she called United, she was told she could keep getting treated at Sylvester until January, under something called continuity of care. Insurers can grant that to some patients in active treatment, like cancer patients, so they can keep seeing a doctor for a while after the doctor leaves the network. Libov wanted it in writing.

She was already planning to look at other Advantage plans, to see which would cover her doctors at Sylvester and at Mount Sinai, the hospital closest to home, in case she had to switch for 2027. She said the stress reminded her what seniors risk when they go with an Advantage plan.

What UnitedHealth spends on care

UnitedHealth’s income statement has a line for medical costs, which is what the company pays doctors and hospitals for its members’ care. Divide that by the premiums coming in, and you get what the company calls the medical care ratio. Whatever United pays UHealth’s doctors goes into that line. UnitedHealth’s annual report says the ratio was 85.5 percent in 2024. In 2025 it was 89.1 percent, so 89.1 cents of every premium dollar went to care. Premiums were $352.2 billion, and medical costs were $314.0 billion.

What a screener saw, and when

Any screener works from what a company has already reported. If you’d run UnitedHealth through one in the spring of 2025, it would have read 85.5 percent, the number for 2024. The first quarter of 2025, reported in April, came in at 84.8 percent, barely up from 84.3 a year before.

On May 12, 2025, the chief executive, Andrew Witty, stepped down, and Stephen Hemsley, the board’s chair, took the job. In July, the company told the SEC it had begun complying with formal criminal and civil requests from the Department of Justice about parts of its Medicare business. Neither of those shows up in a financial statement. On July 29, UnitedHealth reported its numbers for April through June: 89.4 percent, up from 85.1 a year earlier. A screener working from reports only saw the jump then. The annual report, filed on March 2, 2026, put the year at 89.1 and listed what pushed it up: Medicare funding cuts, medical costs rising faster than usual, and a handful of other things.

A fight over a contract with one hospital system may never show up in the numbers at all. UHealth told the Herald it was trying to get coverage extended to the end of the year for more than 26,000 of its patients in plans like Libov’s. In 2025, UnitedHealth took in $352.2 billion in premiums.

Where this breaks

The medical care ratio is one number for tens of millions of people. When it moves, the filing lists the reasons, and a screener can’t weigh them. In the second quarter of 2026, one of the reasons the ratio fell was what UnitedHealth calls favorable prior period reserve development. That means its earlier guesses about what it owed for care already given turned out too high. In its 10-Q, the quarterly report it files with the SEC, UnitedHealth says those corrections for earlier years came to $1,250 million in the first six months of 2026, mostly from what it calls a favorable respiratory illness season.

The ratio also says nothing about any single patient. It can’t tell you whether Libov’s doctors are in or out, or whether a trial can move to another hospital. I wrote about the four questions no column can answer in September 2026. There’s more in what a profit margin hides at Delta and how to read an income statement.

Libov’s plan through December

At the end of July 2026, UHealth and United agreed on a new contract for employer plans, individual plans and Medicaid. Libov’s plan was a separate matter. UHealth says the two sides agreed to extend the Preferred Care Network contract through December 31, and that it ends on January 1, 2027. Open enrollment, when she can pick another plan for 2027, runs from October 15 to December 7, 2026.

From April through June 2026, UnitedHealth’s ratio came in at 86.7 percent, down from 89.4 a year earlier. The 10-Q says net earnings rose to $5,484 million from $3,406 million. Medical costs fell by $3,227 million, to $75,358 million from $78,585 million a year earlier. Premiums barely moved: $86,956 million against $87,905 million. The filing says medical costs fell mainly because the company served fewer people, and because of that correction to earlier years.

If I had UnitedHealth in my portfolio, I’d read the medical care ratio in every quarterly report, and then the list of reasons the filing gives when the ratio moves. I’d set the corrections to earlier years apart, because they come from old guesses about care already given.

To check whether UnitedHealth looks cheap or expensive today, search for it in Bufetico.

UnitedHealth’s medical care ratio comes out after the news, because each quarterly report looks back at three months that are already over.

Key factsThe numbers and where they come from · 9 October 2026
  • UnitedHealth’s medical care ratio, its medical costs divided by premiums, was 85.5 percent in 2024 and 89.1 percent in 2025, when premiums were $352.2 billion and medical costs $314.0 billion (UnitedHealth’s annual report).
  • For the second quarter of 2025, which UnitedHealth reported on July 29, 2025, the ratio was 89.4 percent, up from 85.1 a year earlier. In the first quarter of 2025 it had been 84.8 percent.
  • In the second quarter of 2026, the ratio came in at 86.7 percent and net earnings rose to $5,484 million from $3,406 million, according to UnitedHealth’s quarterly report.
  • UnitedHealth’s quarterly report says its earlier estimates of what it owed for care already given proved too high. Those corrections came to $1,250 million in the first six months of 2026, mostly from a favorable respiratory illness season.

Bufetico puts every company on more than 30 exchanges through the same six layers. Prices update after every market close, and company financials once a month. What passes is decided by thresholds you set yourself. See it.

← All articles

Sold too early, or held on too long?

Join the waitlist and I'll email you when Bufetico opens, plus a new article or tool now and then.

No more than one email a week. You can unsubscribe anytime, and the Privacy Policy explains how we handle your name and email.

Can't tell a cheap stock from a dying one?

The Bufetico Filter checks more than 30,000 companies against six layers and shows you only the ones that pass. You decide how strict each layer is. Bufetico opens soon.

Join the waitlist »