You bought a stock because the P/E looked low, and then the profit under it disappeared. The school superintendent in Upper Darby, Pennsylvania, is worried his district can’t keep a laptop in every student’s hands for much longer.
Dan McGarry jokes that before the pandemic, “a computer was a campfire” in his district: six kids around one machine, warming their hands, because that’s all the district could afford. Federal COVID relief money changed that. McGarry was out in the handout line himself until 8:30 at night, handing out Chromebooks the district had rushed in overnight.
That money is gone. McGarry laid out the numbers for WHYY, Philadelphia’s public broadcaster, in a story in August 2026. Chromebooks that used to cost about $400 a student now cost more than $600, and the district swaps out about 3,000 of them a year. He puts the cost of keeping up at $2 million to $3 million a year. Daniel Kitchen, the district’s technology director, said the price of the average Chromebook goes up 25 percent a year, no matter who sells it.
Going back to the campfire isn’t an option either. Pennsylvania gives its standardized tests online, and paper tests are only for students who need them as an accommodation.
The cause is memory. Benjamin Lee, who teaches computer science and electrical engineering at the University of Pennsylvania, explained it to the station. The big data center operators and AI companies are pouring hundreds of billions of dollars into data centers, and those have to be filled with hardware, memory included. He explained that some of the plants that make memory chips can choose between chips for AI servers and chips for consumer electronics. The more of a plant’s line goes to AI, he said, the less room there may be for laptops. Lee said memory makers are getting profit margins he hasn’t seen in the 20 to 30 years he’s worked in the field. He also said computer hardware is known for its booms and busts.
Micron, based in Boise, Idaho, is one of those memory makers, and its own numbers show those margins. In its quarter to the end of May, it kept 85 cents of every dollar of sales after covering the cost of making its products, compared with 38 cents a year earlier. In those three months it made a profit of $28.2 billion. That’s more than three times the $8.54 billion it made in its whole 2025 fiscal year.
That profit is the E in P/E. A price-to-earnings ratio takes what the market says the whole company is worth and divides it by one year of profit. So it’s one number from the market and twelve months of accounting. When you read a low P/E as a low price, you’re assuming those twelve months were a normal year. For a school district paying half again as much for every Chromebook, 2026 isn’t a normal year.
Micron, year by year
The booms and busts Lee talked about are right there in Micron’s own filings. Every annual report gives a market value for Micron’s shares at the end of February or the start of March. Next to each one, I put the profit for that whole fiscal year, which ends in late August or early September. So each ratio divides a market value from February or March by a year that was only half over at the time. You can only get these exact ratios looking back. The figures are in billions of dollars.
| Fiscal year | Market value, Feb. or March | Profit for the year | Rough P/E |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2018 | 45.0 | 14.14 | 3.2 |
| 2019 | 36.2 | 6.31 | 5.7 |
| 2020 | 44.8 | 2.69 | 16.7 |
| 2021 | 79.9 | 5.86 | 13.6 |
| 2022 | 83.9 | 8.69 | 9.7 |
| 2023 | 47.9 | minus 5.83 | none |
| 2024 | 83.6 | 0.78 | 107 |
| 2025 | 85.7 | 8.54 | 10.0 |
In fiscal 2018 the ratio was 3.2. Profit fell 55 percent the next year and another 57 percent the year after, so the lowest P/E in the table came right at the top of the profit cycle. In fiscal 2024, the thinnest year that still showed a profit, the ratio was 107, the highest in the table. The next year, profit was about eleven times bigger. And fiscal 2023 has no P/E at all, because Micron lost money. In the year the cycle hit bottom, a screener sorting by P/E has no number for it.
The market is kind of guessing what the company makes in a normal year, and the price moves slowly with that guess. The profit swings much harder. Micron’s quarterly report to May 2026 even warns that in some past periods, its prices fell below what its products cost to make. When you divide a slow number by a fast one, the fast one runs the ratio. So on a cyclical company, one whose profit rides its industry’s booms and busts, a low P/E says this year’s profit is high and the market doesn’t believe it’ll last. A high one says the profit is low, and the market doesn’t believe that either. The ratio really tells you where the cycle is, only backwards: low at the top and high at the bottom. And it still looks like a valuation. A P/E on Micron’s profit for fiscal 2026 would divide by the same months that are costing Upper Darby more than $600 a Chromebook.
One year against a whole stretch
Kitchen told WHYY that Upper Darby buys a set number of Chromebooks each year to replace the ones getting old or broken. Buying that way also means no single year’s price decides what all the district’s laptops cost. When a company’s years aren’t alike, I compare the price with its profit over a whole stretch of years, the good ones and the bad ones together. That keeps the ratio from flipping every time the cycle turns, and that’s about all it does.
I still use the P/E. On a business whose profit moves a few percent a year, it’s a decent shortcut. The more the E moves, the more the ratio goes wrong. So before you read a P/E, look at the profit line for the last several years. If it’s a gentle slope, read the ratio. If it looks like a mountain range, the ratio is only telling you which peak or valley you’re standing in.
Where this breaks
The market value in each annual report leaves out the shares held by Micron’s executive officers and directors, and by anyone who owns five percent or more, so each ratio in the table is lower than a P/E on all the shares would be. If you counted all of them, at the price on the last day of each fiscal year, every row could move. I stuck with what the company files, so you can redo the table from its annual reports.
And averaging across a cycle only works if there’s a cycle to average. The table alone holds a year of losses and two years when profit fell by more than half, so Micron’s stretch means something. A business that hasn’t been tested yet, with one long boom and no bust, gives you a stretch that’s all peak. And a couple of huge quarters can swamp the rest. In its quarters to the end of February and the end of May 2026, Micron earned $13.8 billion and $28.2 billion. That’s $42.0 billion together, more than the $41.2 billion that all the years in the table add up to. Any stretch of years that takes in those two quarters leans on them.
Dan McGarry and the other side of the memory boom
McGarry told WHYY he got into education partly to teach Shakespeare. Now, he said, the things he has to worry about all cost money. Micron’s quarterly report splits its business into four units, and one of them makes memory and storage for phones and for PCs, like the laptops his district hands out. In the quarter to May, that unit earned $9.87 billion in operating profit, the profit from running it before interest and taxes. A year earlier it had earned $482 million. The report says that came from higher prices and lower manufacturing costs. And the unit shipped less memory and storage than it had a year before.
Key factsThe numbers and where they come from · 17 September 2026
- A price-to-earnings ratio divides what the market says the whole company is worth by one year of profit.
- In its quarter to the end of May 2026, Micron kept 85 cents of every dollar of sales after covering the cost of making its products, against 38 cents a year earlier (Micron’s quarterly report).
- Micron’s profit for the quarter to May 2026 was $28.2 billion, more than three times the $8.54 billion it made in all of fiscal 2025, the company’s filings show.
- In fiscal 2018, Micron’s profit was $14.14 billion against a market value of $45.0 billion in its annual report, a rough P/E of 3.2. Profit fell 55 percent the next year and another 57 percent the year after.
