Bufetico Join the waitlist
Cheap or expensiveMethod

Why cash flow can't value a bank, and why your numbers on JPMorgan never added up

Arli Renacido shared a Chase account with her grandmother in the Philippines for fifteen years, then couldn't touch it for about three months. Her $44,000 is the reason cash flow can't value a bank: on JPMorgan's books, what moves is the customers' money.
15 September 2026 · · 7 min read

You run the same numbers on a bank that worked on everything else, and what comes out makes no sense. So you either trust a number you don’t believe, or you give up on banks. Arli Renacido was trying to pay a bill for her grandmother when the screen told her the payment couldn’t be completed. The account was a joint one at Chase that she’d shared with her grandmother in the Philippines for fifteen years. She says a branch manager told her the account had been flagged and didn’t explain much. She says a letter came about two weeks after she noticed the freeze, and that there was no suspicious activity. For about three months, she couldn’t get to money her grandmother depended on.

Then the I-Team at ABC7 Chicago, the station’s investigative reporters, reached out to Chase, and Chase released the $44,000. “And I was just like, ‘well, finally, just some movement,’” she told the station.

Chase told the station that protecting customers’ accounts is its top priority. It said that when it spots a transaction that worries it, it acts on it, and that the account terms allow that. Every bank does the same, Chase said. Back in October 2025, a man in Lombard named Jim Gibson had told the same reporter that Chase froze $42,000 of his money for more than a month. As I read those two stories, I kept wondering where Renacido’s $44,000 sat on the bank’s own books while she couldn’t touch it.

It sat under deposits, on the liabilities side, which is the list of what the bank owes. Frozen or not, the bank held that money and owed it back. That’s normal for a deposit, and it’s what makes a bank different from every other company I look at. For a shoe company, the cash in its bank account belongs to the shoe company. For a bank, most of the cash belongs to its customers, and the bank only has it until they ask for it back.

When I went through my own list of close to thirty thousand companies, I found sixty-seven financial companies among the two hundred my tool ranked highest. Financial companies are about one name in ten, so about nineteen of those two hundred would have been normal. Something was pulling them to the top, and any bank’s annual report shows you what.

JPMorgan’s profit, and its cash

JPMorgan Chase earned between $24 billion and $58 billion in every year from 2016 to 2025. Over those same ten years, its annual reports show that its cash from operations, the cash its day-to-day business brings in, was negative in four of them. From its best year to its worst, that number swung by $254,901 million. In 2022 the bank earned $38 billion, and its operating cash was plus $107,119 million. In 2025 it earned $57 billion, and its operating cash was minus $147,782 million. The two lines have nothing to do with each other.

For a normal company, those two lines should move together. Profit is the accountant’s version of the cash, and cash is the version you can spend. When they disagree for a long time, something’s going on, and you want to know what. In a bank they disagree because “cash from operations” means something different when your business is holding other people’s money, Renacido’s included.

What moves the cash line in a bank

A bank’s business is taking deposits, making loans and holding securities to trade. When a customer deposits money, the accountants file it under financing, in the same drawer as borrowed money. The securities the bank holds for trading go under operations. If the bank puts money into that pile, it counts as cash going out. If it lets the pile shrink, it counts as cash coming in. The loans it keeps go under investing, and I’ll leave that section alone here.

So the operating cash line mostly records the bank getting bigger and smaller. In 2020, JPMorgan’s deposits grew by $602,765 million in one year, because the country was flooded with money and a lot of it landed in bank accounts. In 2022, as that reversed, deposits fell by $136,895 million. Those are big moves, and they have nothing to do with how well the bank is run. The operating line swings with the pile the bank holds for trading, and with the other balances next to it in that section. Renacido’s account, or Gibson’s, or yours, is one drop in all that. That’s why, in a bank, the profit line is the calm one and the cash line is the noisy one, the reverse of a normal company. The calm line has a guess inside it, though. How many loans won’t be paid back is management’s own estimate, and that estimate moves.

What my tool was doing with it

For most companies, my tool looks at the cash a business brings in after paying for what it needs, and works out from there what the company might be worth. The whole thing rests on one assumption I’d stopped even noticing: that the cash from operations belongs to the business.

Now point that tool at a bank in a year when the trading pile, or one of the other balances in that section, happens to shrink. The cash comes back through operations, and my tool sees an ocean of it. It treats all of it as the company’s own and hands back a value for the bank that’s far too high. That’s where the sixty-seven companies came from. They were banks in years when those balances happened to be shrinking, measured by a tool that couldn’t tell a customer’s money from the bank’s own.

So what I do instead

I stopped. Banks, insurers and almost every other financial company don’t get a valuation from their cash anymore. Where the number would have been, there’s a gray square, and a gray square is better than a number I know is wrong.

Banks can be valued. People have done it for a century with other tools: what the bank earns on the capital it holds, how much of its lending goes bad, and what it pays on deposits compared to what it charges on loans. The cash a bank brings in isn’t one of those tools.

Where this breaks

At first I threw out a whole sector to fix one measuring problem. That was too much, and I’ve since brought a few companies back. The better fix for the banks is a tool built for them, and the gray square means I haven’t built it yet. I’ve also shown only one bank here, the largest, over ten years, and the picture is clear because it’s an extreme case. A small regional bank with steady deposits will have a much calmer cash line. The mismatch will be harder to see there, and that makes it more dangerous. From the outside, you can’t tell which banks will look like JPMorgan, so I switched the valuation off for all of them.

“Financial company” is a label, and it comes from whoever files the paperwork, so it doesn’t always match what the business does. Some payment companies, financial data companies and stock exchanges carry that label, but they don’t make their living lending money or holding deposits, and their cash behaves like any ordinary company’s. They sat in gray with the banks until November 2026, when a short list of them got their number back. Every other company with that label is still gray. I looked hardest at real estate companies, because they turn an unusually large share of their sales into cash. For them, that turned out to be the business itself, which is renting things out, so they keep their number. Where I drew those lines was a judgment call, and somebody else could draw them somewhere else.

The page Renacido’s money is on

On JPMorgan’s 2025 cash flow statement, the operating section ends at minus $147,782 million. Two sections down, in financing, the deposits line reads plus $153,168 million. That’s customers’ money coming in during the year. At the end of 2025, JPMorgan held $2.6 trillion in deposits. Renacido’s $44,000 was frozen over the year end, so it would have been somewhere in that number.

Now go back up to the operating section. Under “net change in” there’s a line that’s easy to skip: trading assets, minus $156,461 million. Growing the pile of securities the bank holds for trading took that much cash during the year, and on a cash flow statement, growing the pile counts as cash going out. The whole operating section comes to minus $147,782 million. That one line is minus $156,461 million.

Key factsThe numbers and where they come from · 15 September 2026
  • JPMorgan Chase earned between $24 billion and $58 billion in every year from 2016 to 2025, while its cash from operations was negative in four of those ten years (JPMorgan’s annual reports).
  • In 2022 JPMorgan’s cash from operations was plus $107,119 million, and in 2025 it was minus $147,782 million (JPMorgan’s annual reports).
  • JPMorgan’s deposits grew by $602,765 million in 2020 and fell by $136,895 million in 2022 (JPMorgan’s annual reports). A bank’s cash flow statement files customer deposits under financing.
  • On JPMorgan’s 2025 cash flow statement, the change in trading assets was minus $156,461 million, and deposits added $153,168 million in the financing section. JPMorgan held $2.6 trillion in deposits at the end of 2025.

Bufetico puts every company on more than 30 exchanges through the same six layers. Prices update after every market close, and company financials once a month. What passes is decided by thresholds you set yourself. See it.

← All articles

Sold too early, or held on too long?

Join the waitlist and I'll email you when Bufetico opens, plus a new article or tool now and then.

No more than one email a week. You can unsubscribe anytime, and the Privacy Policy explains how we handle your name and email.

Can't tell a cheap stock from a dying one?

The Bufetico Filter checks more than 30,000 companies against six layers and shows you only the ones that pass. You decide how strict each layer is. Bufetico opens soon.

Join the waitlist »