Bufetico Join the waitlist
Cheap or expensiveMethod

You drew a straight line up from the best year: why I cap growth, record egg prices, then a loss

Mike Puglisi didn't lose a hen to the bird flu that sent egg prices to a record, and by February 2026 he was losing money anyway. Why I cap growth, why I put a floor under it, and why the most damage in my own model came from where a projection starts.
16 September 2026 · · 5 min read

You see a company’s best year ever and draw the line straight up from there. Then the next year takes it all back, and you’re stuck with a projection built on that one year. Mike Puglisi, a second-generation egg farmer, didn’t lose a single hen in the bird flu outbreak that sent egg prices to a record, and by February 2026 he was losing money anyway. His company, Puglisi Egg Farms, has two farms, in Delaware and New Jersey, and they turn out 486 million eggs a year.

The outbreak killed 50 million egg-laying hens, CNN reported, citing the American Egg Board. People kept buying eggs while there were fewer hens to lay them, so stores ran short and prices hit records. Then farmers restocked their flocks, supply shot back up, and by February wholesale egg prices were down to 92 cents a dozen. It cost an average farm 98 cents to $1.05 to produce a dozen, according to an agricultural economist at the University of Arkansas. So the average farm was selling eggs for less than they cost to produce. Puglisi called the speed of the fall “remarkable.”

Farmers who did lose birds had it much worse, he said. They’d been out of business for a while, and they came back just as the losses started. That’s what he worried about in 2022, when bird flu hit his own farm and he lost his entire flock.

So in four years Puglisi has been through the year he lost the whole flock, a year of record egg prices, and then a stretch of losing money. Before you can put a value on a business like that, you have to decide which of those years to start from.

Any model that projects a company’s cash into the years ahead has three levers: how fast the cash can grow, how far it can fall, and which year it starts from. I put a cap on how fast, because a few strong years say very little about the next few. If a valuation lets a hot streak run, it ends up made almost entirely of the streak. I also put a floor under how far it can fall. When a company shrinks fast enough, year after year, it stops being something you can value. You’d be putting a price on its disappearance.

CNN wrote that lost birds and low prices together could put smaller egg producers out of business. The head of the American Egg Board warned that family farms would be lost if things stayed this way. A floor gets that case wrong. If a company is going away for good, the floor keeps my number too high. But without a floor, I’d get a precise figure for something that’s stopped being a business.

Where the projection starts is the lever nobody argues about. The growth rate comes from the middle of a whole stretch of years, so one odd year can’t pull it around. But the number that grows is a single year’s cash, and the obvious pick is the latest full year. Egg farmers went from record prices to selling at a loss in about a year. Whichever of those years you picked as your starting point, you’d be growing one odd year of the business. In my own model, that lever did the most damage of the three, and it happened with Amazon. The latest year gave a small number, because the model counted everything Amazon spent to grow as money lost. The fix was to stop counting that spending as a loss. That changed what went into the latest year. But the model starts from the latest year all the same, so that lever is still open.

Cal-Maine Foods, the largest egg company in the United States, went through the same boom and bust, and it files its numbers with the SEC. It splits its eggs into conventional ones and specialty ones, like cage-free and organic. Almost all the conventional ones are priced, at least in part, off the wholesale market. In its fiscal year that ended May 31, 2025, the year of the record prices, its conventional eggs made $1,290.0 million after the costs of producing and selling them. The next year they made $216.6 million, about a sixth as much. The annual report says their sales fell mainly because prices did, and that volumes, the number of eggs it sold, were relatively flat. Start a projection from the record, and every year after it inherits a bird-flu price.

Where this breaks

Both limits are blunt. The cap treats a company that really will keep growing fast exactly like one that won’t, and it’ll be wrong about that company every year until the growth stops. The floor makes the same mistake the other way. And a bad stretch of a cycle can look just like a real decline, which is a test of its own. I accept being wrong by a limited amount about a few companies, because it saves me from being wrong without limit about many.

The starting year is harder. If a company’s recent cash has gone negative, my model won’t start from that year, and the company’s square stays gray, with no figure in it. But a record year looks healthy all the way down the page, so that rule never catches it. A warning next to the figure only catches some of the odd years that are left. For the rest, I don’t have a rule that wouldn’t also catch companies that are simply doing badly, and that’s a different thing. So I leave that weak spot where you can see it. And the Cal-Maine figures above are the conventional eggs’ own profit, after the costs of producing and selling them and nothing else. My model projects the whole company’s cash, which rose and fell with the conventional eggs.

Puglisi’s flock

Cal-Maine’s annual report shows three years side by side, and the oldest is the year before the record. In that fiscal year, which ended June 1, 2024, its conventional eggs made $213.7 million. In the one that ended May 30, 2026, they made $216.6 million. Put the record between those two and it looks like one odd year between two normal ones. A projection from the latest full year started from the record, and it stayed that way for a whole year, until the next report came out. But earlier in that same report, next to its wholesale price chart, Cal-Maine says bird flu had a significant effect on egg prices in all three of those years, fiscal 2024 through 2026. And the report for the record year says the same about fiscal 2023 through 2025. So the year before the record was a bird-flu year too. And the one before that, fiscal 2023, was a boom of its own. Cal-Maine says the wholesale egg price it quotes fell 34 percent the next year, as supply recovered from the bird flu that ran through most of 2022. That’s the outbreak that took Puglisi’s whole flock.

Key factsThe numbers and where they come from · 16 September 2026
  • The bird flu outbreak killed 50 million egg-laying hens, CNN reported in February 2026, citing the American Egg Board. By then, wholesale egg prices were down to 92 cents a dozen.
  • Cal-Maine Foods, the largest egg company in the United States, says its conventional eggs made $1,290.0 million in fiscal 2025, which ended May 31, 2025, after the costs of producing and selling them.
  • In fiscal 2026, which ended May 30, 2026, Cal-Maine’s conventional eggs made $216.6 million. Its annual report says sales fell mainly because prices did, and that volumes were relatively flat.
  • Cal-Maine’s conventional eggs made $213.7 million in fiscal 2024, which ended June 1, 2024. The company says the wholesale egg price it quotes fell 34 percent that year as supply recovered from bird flu.

Bufetico puts every company on more than 30 exchanges through the same six layers. Prices update after every market close, and company financials once a month. What passes is decided by thresholds you set yourself. See it.

← All articles

Sold too early, or held on too long?

Join the waitlist and I'll email you when Bufetico opens, plus a new article or tool now and then.

No more than one email a week. You can unsubscribe anytime, and the Privacy Policy explains how we handle your name and email.

Can't tell a cheap stock from a dying one?

The Bufetico Filter checks more than 30,000 companies against six layers and shows you only the ones that pass. You decide how strict each layer is. Bufetico opens soon.

Join the waitlist »