Bufetico Join the waitlist

By

Debt payoff calculator

Paying only the minimums can keep you in debt for decades. List what you owe and see your debt-free date three ways, side by side, and every dollar of interest you’d pay.

bufetico.com/tools/debt-payoff-calculator ·

An educational tool, not financial or investment advice. It’s free, with no sign-up and no ads. The result comes from the numbers you put in, and the pay-or-invest panel uses S&P 500 history.

What you owe

Try an example:
Promo rate

With deferred interest, if any balance is left when the promo ends, the interest it skipped gets added back.

Promo rate

With deferred interest, if any balance is left when the promo ends, the interest it skipped gets added back.

Promo rate

With deferred interest, if any balance is left when the promo ends, the interest it skipped gets added back.

Promo rate

With deferred interest, if any balance is left when the promo ends, the interest it skipped gets added back.

Promo rate

With deferred interest, if any balance is left when the promo ends, the interest it skipped gets added back.

APR is the yearly rate on your statement. Order only counts for Your order, and 1 gets paid off first.

$

On top of all the minimums. It goes to one debt at a time.

Optional. You’ll see the extra a month it takes.

Credit card minimums

On most cards the minimum falls as the balance falls. That’s why cards take so long to pay off.

%

$

One-time and yearly payments
$

Every 12 months, starting in month 12. A tax refund or a bonus, say.

Like 2027-04: 2500, or 6: 1000 for month 6 of the plan, with a semicolon between them.

Compare a balance transfer

Type in the offer you have. It moves your credit card balances, the highest rate first, and keeps your monthly budget the same.

$

Leave it empty to move all your card balances.

%

%

%

Compare a consolidation loan

Type in the loan you were offered. The fee comes out of the loan, so you borrow a little more to pay everything off.

%

%

One credit card

$

%

%

$

Most cards have a floor like $25 or $35.

$

Leave it empty to keep paying the first minimum every month.

Your target. 36 months is the 3-year figure on US card statements.

Debt-free with the avalanche

May 2030 in 3 years and 7 months

You’d pay $6,333 in interest and $48,983 in all, on $42,650 of debt. Your monthly budget is $1,156: the minimums plus your extra.

Paying only the minimums: debt-free in October 2036, with $13,261 in interest. This plan saves you $6,928 in interest, and you’re done 6 years and 5 months sooner.

The avalanche costs $265.87 less in interest than the snowball. The snowball pays off its first debt in 3 months, the avalanche in 1 year and 5 months. Your order: debt-free in May 2030, with $6,516 in interest.

The math picks the order. The hard part is paying the same amount every month until the last debt is gone. That takes the same emotional muscle investing does.

Pay the debt or invest?

Say you paid only the minimums and invested the rest of your monthly budget instead. In May 2030, the month your plan clears the debt, you’d still owe $15,777.

The money invested would have grown to between $7,081 and $18,917, with $14,335 in the middle. That’s going by every 4-year stretch of the S&P 500 since 1928, dividends included. Investing came out ahead in 18 of those 95 stretches.

By then, paying the debt first is sure to save you $4,086 of interest, at an average rate of 9.7%. The market numbers are a range from past years, and they don’t tell you what comes next. Taxes on investment gains aren’t counted. Which one you pick is up to you.

S&P 500 total returns with dividends, 1928 to 2025: Aswath Damodaran, NYU Stern, updated January 2026. S&P 500 is a registered trademark of Standard & Poor’s Financial Services LLC, and the index is a product of S&P Dow Jones Indices LLC. Bufetico isn’t affiliated with them or endorsed by them.

Three orders, side by side
OrderDebt-freeInterestYou save
AvalancheMay 2030$6,333$6,928
SnowballMay 2030$6,599$6,662
Your orderMay 2030$6,516$6,745
Minimums onlyOct 2036$13,261

You save: the interest you skip compared to paying only the minimums.

What you owe, month by month

AvalancheSnowballYour orderMinimums only

When each debt is paid off

DebtPaid offInterestMinimums only
Card 1Mar 2028$1,213May 2031
Card 2Jul 2028$725.04Aug 2031
Car loanApr 2029$1,664May 2030
Medical billMar 2028$0Mar 2028
Student loanMay 2030$2,731Oct 2036

Month by month

MonthPaidInterestOwed afterPaid off
Nov 2026$1,156$344.85$41,839
Dec 2026$1,156$335.55$41,018
Jan 2027$1,156$326.08$40,188
Feb 2027$1,156$316.46$39,349
Mar 2027$1,156$306.67$38,500
Apr 2027$1,156$296.72$37,640
May 2027$1,156$286.60$36,771
Jun 2027$1,156$276.31$35,891
Jul 2027$1,156$265.84$35,001
Aug 2027$1,156$255.19$34,100
Sep 2027$1,156$244.36$33,189
Oct 2027$1,156$233.34$32,266
Nov 2027$1,156$222.13$31,332
Dec 2027$1,156$210.73$30,387
Jan 2028$1,156$199.13$29,430
Feb 2028$1,156$187.33$28,461
Mar 2028$1,156$175.33$27,481Card 1, Medical bill
Apr 2028$1,156$163.33$26,488
May 2028$1,156$151.10$25,483
Jun 2028$1,156$138.67$24,466
Jul 2028$1,156$126.05$23,436Card 2
Aug 2028$1,156$118.03$22,398
Sep 2028$1,156$111.98$21,354
Oct 2028$1,156$105.90$20,304
Nov 2028$1,156$99.78$19,247
Dec 2028$1,156$93.63$18,185
Jan 2029$1,156$87.44$17,117
Feb 2029$1,156$81.21$16,042
Mar 2029$1,156$74.95$14,961
Apr 2029$1,156$68.65$13,873Car loan
May 2029$1,156$63.59$12,781
Jun 2029$1,156$58.58$11,683
Jul 2029$1,156$53.55$10,581
Aug 2029$1,156$48.50$9,474
Sep 2029$1,156$43.42$8,361
Oct 2029$1,156$38.32$7,243
Nov 2029$1,156$33.20$6,120
Dec 2029$1,156$28.05$4,993
Jan 2030$1,156$22.88$3,859
Feb 2030$1,156$17.69$2,721
Mar 2030$1,156$12.47$1,578
Apr 2030$1,156$7.23$428.80
May 2030$430.76$1.97$0Student loan
Show the math

Interest each month = balance x APR / 12

Each month: pay every minimum, then the rest of the budget goes to the first debt in the order, and anything left over to the next one.

Budget = minimums of the first month + extra = $1,156 a month

Fixed payment for n months = balance x i / (1 - (1 + i)^-n), with i = APR / 12

How this calculator works

Each month, every debt charges interest: its balance times its APR, divided by 12. Then the calculator pays every minimum. Whatever is left of your monthly budget goes to one debt, the first one in the order you picked, until it’s gone. When a debt is paid off, its payment moves to the next one, so the amount going out each month stays the same until the end.

I filled the boxes with 5 made-up debts that add up to $42,650: two credit cards, a car loan, a medical bill and a student loan, with $250 extra a month. That’s a budget of $1,156 a month. If you pay the highest rate first, the last debt is gone in May 2030, after 3 years and 7 months, with $6,333 in interest. Paying only the minimums takes 10 years and costs $13,261 in interest.

Card statements in the US work out their estimates the same basic way. The rules behind them, Regulation Z, let the bank assume a monthly rate, payments at the end of each month and no new charges (Appendix M1). Your bank charges interest by the day, so your real numbers can be off by a few dollars.

Avalanche, snowball or your own order

The avalanche pays the highest interest rate first. It’s the order that usually costs the least interest. The snowball pays the smallest balance first. It costs more, but the first debt is gone sooner, and watching one disappear can keep you going.

With the example in the boxes, the avalanche costs $265.87 less in interest than the snowball. The snowball clears its first debt in 3 months. The avalanche takes 1 year and 5 months. Your order, with the medical bill first and then the highest rates, lands in between, with $6,516 in interest.

The difference between the two is often smaller than people expect, so pick the order you’ll stick with. A plan you drop after six months costs more than either of them.

The minimum payment trap

On most credit cards the minimum is a small percent of the balance, often 1% plus that month’s interest, with a floor like $25. As the balance falls, the minimum falls with it, so the payment keeps shrinking and the interest keeps eating most of it.

The second tab shows it with one card: $5,000 at 22.36%. The first minimum is $143.17. Paying only the minimum takes 19 years and 3 months and costs $8,241 in interest. Keep paying that same $143.17 every month and it’s gone in 4 years and 9 months, with $3,158 in interest. To be done in 3 years, you’d pay $191.88 a month and $1,908 in interest.

If a minimum doesn’t even cover the interest, the balance never goes down. The calculator tells you when that happens, for each debt.

Balance transfers and consolidation loans

A balance transfer moves card debt to a card with a low rate for a while, usually for a fee of a few percent. It only works if most of the balance is gone when the promo ends. Type in the offer you have and the calculator tells you what you’d need to pay each month to clear it in time, and how much would be left at the end with your plan.

A consolidation loan pays off several debts, and you’re left with one fixed payment. A lower payment can still cost more in total if the loan runs longer, and the origination fee comes out of the money you get. The calculator puts each offer next to your debts as they are today.

Watch for deferred interest on store cards and medical financing. If even a small balance is left when the promo ends, the interest the promo skipped gets added back. Mark the debt as deferred interest and the calculator adds it in the month it would hit.

Paying off debt or investing

Paying off a debt at 22% gives you a 22% return, and you know you’ll get it. With the market, you never know. The panel shows the two next to each other: the interest you save by paying the debt first, and what the same money would have done in the S&P 500 in every stretch of years since 1928. That includes the bad ones.

With high-rate card debt, the market needed a very good stretch to come out ahead. With a 4% car loan, it often did. Either way it’s your call. Holding stocks through the bad years while you still owe money takes a strong stomach. Whether you have it is part of the decision too.

S&P 500 is a registered trademark of Standard & Poor’s Financial Services LLC, and the index is a product of S&P Dow Jones Indices LLC. Bufetico isn’t affiliated with them or endorsed by them.

What a debt payoff calculator doesn’t see

There are a few things a debt payoff calculator can’t see.

  • New charges. If you keep using a card, its balance doesn’t fall the way the plan says. The plan assumes you stop.
  • Rates that change. A variable rate moves with the market, and a late payment can bring a penalty rate, but here each rate stays where you put it.
  • Daily interest. Banks charge interest by the day, and months have different lengths. The calculator uses a monthly rate, so expect a few dollars of difference.
  • Fees. Annual fees, late fees and over-limit fees aren’t counted.
  • Student loan plans. If your payment depends on your income, or your loans are in deferment or headed for forgiveness, the math changes. Use your current payment, and check with your loan servicer.
  • Taxes. Some interest, like mortgage or student loan interest, can lower your taxes, and that tax break isn’t in the math.
  • Your credit score. Closing a card after you pay it off can change your credit score, which this calculator doesn’t track.

For what your money could grow to once the debt is gone, try the investment calculator.

Questions people ask

Snowball or avalanche: which one should I use?

The avalanche, highest rate first, usually saves the most interest. The snowball, smallest balance first, gets you a win sooner. Run both in the calculator: if the difference is small, pick the one you’ll stick with. If it’s large, the avalanche is paying you to be patient.

Why does paying only the minimum take so long?

Because on most cards the minimum falls as the balance falls. Most of each payment goes to interest, and the payment keeps shrinking. A fixed payment, even the same as your first minimum, cuts years off. The second tab shows it with your card.

Why doesn’t this match my statement?

Your bank charges interest by the day, on the balance of each day, and your payment date matters. This calculator uses a monthly rate with payments at the end of the month, the way US card statements are allowed to estimate it. New charges and fees also change it. Use it to compare plans, and check your statement for the exact payoff amount.

What if my payment doesn’t cover the interest?

Then the balance never goes down, and if you pay only that amount, you never pay off the debt. The calculator warns you for each debt. To fix it, pay more on that debt or put it first in the order.

Should I do a balance transfer or a consolidation loan?

It depends on the numbers in your own offer. Type them in and compare: the total cost with the fee, the monthly payment you’d need, and what’s left when a promo ends. Both usually need a credit check, and neither helps if the cards fill up again.

Should I pay off debt or invest?

The interest you avoid is certain, and the market’s return isn’t. You can see both in the panel, with your numbers and every stretch of S&P 500 history since 1928. The calculator can’t weigh two things: an employer match in a retirement plan, which you’d give up by not contributing, and an emergency fund, which keeps a surprise bill from going back on a card.

I don’t know my APR. What should I put in?

Look at your statement or your account online. If you need a starting point, the Federal Reserve’s averages for August 2026, published October 7, 2026, were 21.19% for credit card plans (22.36% on accounts charged interest), 11.9% for a 24-month personal loan and 7.17% for a 72-month new car loan (Federal Reserve, G.19).

What is deferred interest?

A promo where the interest isn’t waived, only postponed. If any balance is left when the promo ends, the interest it skipped is added back. Open Promo rate on the debt, put in the months left and check Deferred interest. The calculator warns you if your plan doesn’t clear it in time.

Can I plan biweekly payments?

Paying half your payment every two weeks adds up to 13 monthly payments a year instead of 12. Put one month’s payment in Extra once a year and you’ll see what that extra payment does.

Can I include my mortgage and student loans?

Yes. Add them like any other debt. With the avalanche, a low-rate mortgage usually ends up last. For student loans, use the payment you make today.

Is my data saved or sent anywhere?

No. Everything is calculated in your browser, and there’s no sign-up or bank login. The link you copy holds your numbers, so share it only with people you trust.

Before you decide

This calculator is an educational tool. It does the math on the numbers you enter. It also shows data from other sources, like the history of the S&P 500. And it shows figures measured in Bufetico’s own data. This page gives the source and date of each one. That data can have errors and can go out of date. The past doesn’t tell you what comes next. The calculator doesn’t know your situation. Its result is hypothetical and changes with every input. It doesn’t guarantee anything. None of this is investment, tax or legal advice, or a recommendation to buy, hold or sell any security. Neither Bufetico nor JH Grandgerard is a registered investment adviser, a broker or a tax adviser. Bufetico sells a subscription to a stock screener, and this page links to it.

Terms for the free tools

Sold too early, or held on too long?

Join the waitlist and I'll email you when Bufetico opens, plus a new article or tool now and then.

No more than one email a week. You can unsubscribe anytime, and the Privacy Policy explains how we handle your name and email.

Can't tell a cheap stock from a dying one?

The Bufetico Filter checks more than 30,000 companies against six layers and shows you only the ones that pass. You decide how strict each layer is. Bufetico opens soon.

Join the waitlist »