How this calculator works
Each month, the calculator grows your money by the return you put in. Then it takes out that month’s share of every yearly fee: the expense ratio, the advisor fee and any other fee in %, each on what you have that month, plus a twelfth of the flat fee. A front-end load comes off each deposit before it’s invested, and a back-end load comes off at the end, when you sell. Next to your options, it runs the same plan with no fees at all. The gap between the two is what the fees cost you.
With the numbers already in the boxes, $10,000 to start and $500 a month for 30 years at 7% a year, you put in $190,000. With no fees, that grows to $664,155. The index fund at 0.05% ends with $657,234, the active fund at 0.64% with $581,517, and the active fund with a 1% advisor fee on top with $475,081. That last one loses 28.5% of the money you could have had.
I picked 7% to stay on the careful side. The S&P 500 returned 10.02% a year from 1928 to 2025 counting the bad years and with dividends put back in. For inflation I put in 3%, close to the 3.04% a year US prices rose over those same years. The fund fees are what fund investors paid on average in 2025: 0.05% in index stock funds and 0.64% in actively managed ones. And 1% is the advisor fee you hear about most.
S&P 500 is a registered trademark of Standard & Poor’s Financial Services LLC, and the index is a product of S&P Dow Jones Indices LLC. Bufetico isn’t affiliated with them or endorsed by them.
What a fee costs: the fee and the growth it takes with it
A fee takes money out of your account, and that money stops growing. With the active fund and the advisor in the example, you’d pay $91,550 in fees over 30 years. The other $97,524 of the cost is growth those dollars would have made if they’d stayed invested, and it’s the part that makes a small fee so expensive over the years.
A fee is also a share of your return. The active fund with the advisor starts at 1.64% a year. That’s about 23% of a 7% return. After 3% inflation, the return is about 3.88%, and the fees take about 42% of that.
What a normal expense ratio is
| Fund type, 2025 | Average expense ratio |
|---|---|
| Index stock mutual funds | 0.05% |
| Index stock ETFs | 0.14% |
| Money market funds | 0.24% |
| Target-date mutual funds | 0.27% |
| Bond mutual funds | 0.36% |
| Stock mutual funds, all | 0.40% |
| Actively managed stock mutual funds | 0.64% |
These are the averages fund investors actually paid in 2025, weighted by how much money was in each fund. They come from the Investment Company Institute’s report Trends in the Expenses and Fees of Funds, 2025, published in March 2026. The plain average of all stock mutual funds, counting each fund the same, was 1.08%. It’s higher because most of the money sits in the cheaper funds. In 2025, 92% of the money going into long-term mutual funds went to funds with no load and no 12b-1 fee, up from 46% in 2000.
Fees that aren’t in the expense ratio
The expense ratio is only the fund’s own yearly fee. An advisor charges on top of it. The rate is in the advisor’s brochure, Form ADV Part 2A, and you can look it up on the SEC’s Investment Adviser Public Disclosure site. A 401(k) plan can add an administrative or recordkeeping fee, and the plan has to send you a yearly notice with its fees. Some brokers charge a yearly account fee. A load comes off when you buy or when you sell.
Two more costs don’t show up as a fee at all. When a fund buys and sells stocks, it pays commissions and the gap between the buying and selling price, and that comes out of the fund’s returns. A fund that trades a lot pays more of it, and you can put a guess under “Other yearly fees.” In a taxable account, a fund that trades a lot also pays out more gains each year, and you pay tax on them. Pick “Taxable brokerage account” and put in each fund’s turnover to see a rough estimate.
Loads, share classes and the legal limits
A front-end load, common in A shares, comes off each purchase, and it gets smaller for bigger purchases. Those lower rates start at amounts called breakpoints, and the prospectus lists them. A back-end load, also called a contingent deferred sales charge, comes off when you sell and usually shrinks each year you hold. C shares often charge 1% if you sell within about a year. They have no front-end load and carry a higher yearly 12b-1 fee.
FINRA’s Rule 2341 sets the limits for the funds a broker can sell. Front-end and deferred loads together can’t go above 8.5% of the offering price, and the cap is lower when the fund also pays a service fee. The yearly sales charge taken from the fund can’t go above 0.75% of its assets, plus a service fee of up to 0.25%. And a fund can only be called no-load if it has no load and those yearly charges stay at 0.25% or less.
Is a costlier option ever worth it?
It can be, if it earns more after its fees. The calculator shows how much more it needs. With the numbers in the boxes, the active fund with the advisor would have to earn 1.72 points more than the index fund every year for 30 years, before fees, just to come out even. S&P Dow Jones Indices keeps score of this in its SPIVA reports. In the 15 years through December 2024, there was no fund category where most active managers beat their benchmark.
An advisor can earn the fee in other ways, like a plan for your taxes or keeping you invested in a bad year, and only you can put a number on that. I lean toward simple and cheap myself, because the fee is the one part of investing you know before you start.
Fees in retirement
In retirement, fees come out of the money you live on. The “In retirement” tab starts with $500,000 at retirement, takes out $25,000 the first year and a little more each year with inflation, and earns 7% a year. The money lasts 38 years and 8 months with no fees, 38 years with the index fund, and 26 years and 8 months with the active fund and the advisor. To make it last 30 years, you could start at $28,129 a year with the index fund and $22,959 with the active fund and the advisor.
What a fee calculator doesn’t see
A fee calculator can miss six things.
- A steady return. The calculator gives every year the same return. Real markets swing, so try a lower and a higher return and look at the range.
- Fees that change. Funds cut and raise their fees, and an advisor’s rate can change. The calculator keeps each one fixed.
- Costs inside the fund. Trading costs come out of the fund’s returns without showing up in the expense ratio.
- Taxes when you sell. The results are before any tax you pay when you sell, and the tax from turnover is a rough estimate.
- Breakpoints. A front-end load drops as you buy more, and some funds count your family’s accounts too. The calculator uses the one rate you type.
- What advice is worth. The calculator sees the advisor’s fee. It has no way to put a value on the advice itself.
To see how a yearly fee stretches the time your money takes to double, use the rule of 72 calculator. To see how a stock really did with its fees, use the stock profit calculator.
Questions people ask
What is an expense ratio?
It’s the fund’s yearly fee, as a percent of what you have in it. An expense ratio of 0.5% costs $5 a year for every $1,000 you hold. It pays for running the fund: the managers, the paperwork and, if there is one, the 12b-1 fee for selling it.
How is the expense ratio charged?
You never get a bill, which is why it’s easy to forget. The fund takes a tiny slice every day from its own assets, so each share’s price is a little lower than it would be without the fee. The calculator takes it out once a month, which works out the same for all practical purposes.
What is a good expense ratio?
The Investment Company Institute says that in 2025, fund investors paid 0.05% on average in index stock funds and 0.64% in actively managed stock funds, weighted by assets. Compare funds of the same kind: a bond index fund and a small-company stock fund cost different amounts to run.
How much does a 1% fee cost over 30 years?
With $10,000 to start and $500 a month at 7% a year, a fund at 1% ends with $116,957 less than one at 0.05%. The 1% fund’s fees take 18.7% of the money you could have had, and you’d pay $60,951 in fees along the way. The SEC has its own example: $100,000 growing 4% a year for 20 years comes to about $208,000 with a 0.25% fee and about $179,000 with 1%.
Is a 1% advisor fee worth it?
It depends on what you get for it, and that’s your call. The calculator shows the cost: with the numbers in the boxes, the active fund at 0.64% plus the advisor’s 1% costs about the same as earning 1.74 points less every year. Ask the advisor what the fee covers, whether there are other fees, and whether they act as a fiduciary, which means they have to put your interest first.
What is the difference between an expense ratio and an advisor fee?
The expense ratio is the fund’s fee, and you pay it to the fund. The advisor fee is what you pay the person who picks the funds for you. If you have both, you pay both, so put both in the same column.
What is a 12b-1 fee?
It’s the part of a fund’s expense ratio that pays for marketing and selling the fund, and it often goes to the broker who sold it to you. It’s already inside the expense ratio. Put it in the 12b-1 row only to see how much of your fees went to it.
What are front-end and back-end loads?
They’re sales charges. A front-end load comes off when you buy, so less of your money gets invested. A back-end load comes off when you sell, and usually gets smaller each year you hold. Funds sold with no load at all are called no-load funds.
Should I enter the return before or after fees?
Before. Put in what the investments themselves earn, and the calculator takes the fees out. If you look up an index’s past return, that’s before fees, because nobody pays fees to an index.
Do ETFs and index funds have expense ratios?
Yes, though they’re usually low. In 2025 the average was 0.14% for index stock ETFs and 0.05% for index stock mutual funds, weighted by assets. Buying and selling an ETF also costs the small gap between the buying and selling price. You can enter that as a small front-end load.
What fees does a 401(k) have?
The funds’ expense ratios, and often a plan fee for recordkeeping and administration, as a percent of your balance or a flat amount. Put the percent under “Other yearly fees” and a flat amount under “Flat fee a year.” Your plan sends a yearly notice with its fees.
How do I find out what I pay?
A fund lists its fees in the fee table near the front of the prospectus, and on the fund’s page. An advisor’s fee is in your agreement and in the Form ADV Part 2A brochure. A 401(k) plan sends a yearly fee notice, and a brokerage account has a fee schedule.
How do taxes from turnover work?
When a fund sells stocks at a gain, it has to pay out those gains, and in a taxable account you owe tax on them that year, even if you reinvest. A fund that trades a lot pays out more. The calculator assumes the fund cashes in the same share of each year’s gain as its turnover. That’s a rough estimate. For a real fund, compare its return before taxes with its return after taxes on distributions, both in the prospectus.
Flat fee or a percentage: which costs less?
Divide the flat fee by the percentage to find the balance where they cost the same. A $3,000 flat fee and a 1% fee cost the same on $300,000. Above that, the flat fee costs less, and the gap grows as your balance grows. Put one in each column to see it over the years.
How do fees change how long my retirement money lasts?
Every year, the fee comes out on top of what you take, so the money runs out sooner. With $500,000 and $25,000 a year to start, the money lasts 38 years with the index fund and 26 years and 8 months with the active fund and the advisor. The “In retirement” tab works it out with your numbers.
Does a lower fee always mean a better fund?
Not always. A costlier fund has to beat the cheaper one by more than the difference in fees, every year, just to come out even. The calculator tells you how much more. Compare funds that invest in the same kinds of stocks or bonds.
How do I work out fees in Excel or Google Sheets?
For one amount and a yearly fee, =FV(7%-1%, 30, 0, -10000) gives roughly what $10,000 becomes at 7% with a 1% fee, and =FV(7%, 30, 0, -10000) with no fee. The gap is the cost. Taking 1% off the return is close enough for a quick check. The calculator does it month by month, with your deposits.