Bufetico Join the waitlist
StableCase study

The dividend keeps coming, so you don't look: Coca-Cola paid out more than its business brought in

Dale Hemminger has been farming for 50 years and says companies like fairlife are coming back. Coca-Cola, which owns fairlife, paid out more in dividends than its business brought in two years running. Where the money came from, and why milk is half the answer.
23 September 2026 · · 6 min read

The dividend lands in your account and you stop thinking about it. You never ask where the company got the cash to pay it. Dale Hemminger watched New York lose ground in the milk business for most of his career.

He owns Hemdale Farms in Ontario County. He says New York was the number two dairy state when he got out of high school, and that recently it was number five. In August 2026, in a Spectrum News story about a new plant near Rochester, he said “great companies like Fairlife and others are coming back to New York.” He added that many energy drinks have milk components in them now, and that local processors and buyers, fairlife among them, are a big part of that.

The plant belongs to fairlife, the milk brand Coca-Cola owns. It’s a $650 million plant in Webster, and at full production it’ll take in five to six million pounds of milk a day from New York farms. Becca Kerr, who runs fairlife, called it one of the largest capital investments Coca-Cola has ever made, and said demand for fairlife’s products has never been higher.

For farmers like Hemminger, that plant is a buyer. Governor Kathy Hochul said it will give the state’s dairy farmers a dependable market, and at the ribbon cutting she told Kerr that Webster is the next place for fairlife to expand.

That new buyer belongs to a company that spent 2024 and 2025 paying its shareholders more than its business brought in. In 2025 Coca-Cola paid $8,779 million in dividends, and the business itself brought in $7,408 million of cash. The year before, $8,359 million went out and $6,805 million came in. And in February 2026 the board raised the dividend again, for the 64th year in a row.

Profit and cash sit in different pockets

A dividend goes out the door as cash, so I measure it against cash. The 2025 dividend was 67 percent of profit, which sounds comfortable. But it was 119 percent of the cash the business brought in.

When I see that, I open the cash flow statement in the annual report, the page that shows where the money came from and where it went. I look at what’s sitting inside the operating number, the cash that came from running the business. At Coca-Cola there are two big payments in there, one in each year, and neither one was a cost of running the business that year.

The two payments

One of them has to do with the brand Hemminger was talking about. When Coca-Cola bought the rest of fairlife in 2020, the deal tied the final price to how well fairlife did through 2024, with no cap. And fairlife did well. The last payment, $6.2 billion, went out in March 2025, and $6.1 billion of it was counted in the cash from running the business. That one payment was more than nine times the $650 million Webster plant.

The other is a long way from any dairy farm. It’s a fight with the IRS over how much of the profit made abroad the U.S. company should pay tax on. Both sides had agreed on a formula, and the IRS signed off on it in five audits in a row. Then, for 2007 through 2009, it switched to a different one. The Tax Court mostly sided with the IRS. So in September 2024, Coca-Cola put down $6.0 billion, the tax plus interest, as a deposit that stops more interest from piling up while it appeals. If it wins, the money comes back, all of it or part of it.

Add the two payments back, and the business brought in something like $12.8 billion in 2024 and $13.5 billion in 2025. In 2023, a year with no payment anywhere near that size, it brought in $11,599 million. So the cash from the business kept growing, but each year a giant bill sat on top of it.

Coca-Cola covered the gap between the dividend and the cash mostly by selling bottlers, the companies that bottle and deliver its drinks. It sold its bottling business in the Philippines, its stake in Coke Consolidated (a U.S. bottler) and part of its bottler in India. In 2024 it also borrowed more than it paid back. Buybacks, the money a company spends buying back its own shares, went down in 2024 and again in 2025, while the dividend kept going up. The company’s own list of priorities puts growing the dividend second and buybacks last.

Where this breaks

Both payments were real cash out the door, and the tax money might never come back. Adding it back only works if Coca-Cola wins its appeal. The federal appeals court heard the case on June 25, 2026. When Coca-Cola filed its report for the quarter that ended July 3, 2026, the court hadn’t ruled. If the IRS wins, some or all of the $6.0 billion stays with the IRS. In that case, the company says the years since, 2010 through 2025, would cost it about $14 billion more, and that the IRS’s formula would raise its yearly tax bill too.

I got the $12.8 and $13.5 billion myself, by adding the two payments back to the cash the company reported. Other things moved inside the cash flow statement in those years too, like a lift in 2024 from selling customers’ unpaid bills to banks, and tax deposits in Israel and Vietnam in 2025. I only pulled out the two that are big enough to cover the gap.

Hemminger’s great company, on Coca-Cola’s books

Hemminger called fairlife a great company. On Coca-Cola’s books, for a while, that looked like bad news. The better fairlife did, the bigger that last bill got, and Coca-Cola had to book every increase against its profit: $3,109 million in 2024 alone, months before the cash went out. When the deal closed in 2020, Coca-Cola valued everything it might owe fairlife’s sellers at $270 million.

And this is Coca-Cola in Bufetico. The screen has three parts: cheap or expensive on top, financially stable in the middle, and growing at the bottom.

Coca-Cola in Bufetico at the close on October 15, 2026: the Gap (cash) in red under cheap or expensive, debt in orange and profit and cash in green under financially stable, and sales in orange, flat, under growing
Coca-Cola in Bufetico at the close on October 15, 2026. Cheap or expensive, on top, is red. Profit and cash are green. Debt is orange, and so are sales, which are flat.

If Coca-Cola were in my portfolio, I’d open the cash flow statement in its annual report and put the dividends paid next to the cash from running the business. Then I’d look for any payment inside it as big as the last fairlife payment or the IRS deposit, and figure out what the business brought in without it.

If you own Coca-Cola or you’re about to buy it, the business makes a good profit, but its sales are flat. And its price is way above what Coca-Cola is worth, going by the cash it brings in each year, so to me it’s expensive.

Part of the dividend that landed in your account in 2024 and 2025 was paid with money from selling bottlers.

Key factsThe numbers and where they come from · 23 September 2026
  • In 2025, Coca-Cola paid $8,779 million in dividends, 119 percent of the $7,408 million of cash its business brought in. In 2024, $8,359 million went out and $6,805 million came in (Coca-Cola’s annual report).
  • The last payment for fairlife, the milk brand Coca-Cola owns, went out in March 2025. It was $6.2 billion, and $6.1 billion of it was counted inside Coca-Cola’s cash from running the business.
  • After the Tax Court mostly sided with the IRS in a dispute over profit made abroad, Coca-Cola put down $6.0 billion in September 2024, the tax plus interest, as a deposit while it appeals.
  • Coca-Cola’s board raised the dividend again in February 2026, for the 64th year in a row.

Bufetico puts every company on more than 30 exchanges through the same six layers. Prices update after every market close, and company financials once a month. What passes is decided by thresholds you set yourself. See it.

← All articles

Sold too early, or held on too long?

Join the waitlist and I'll email you when Bufetico opens, plus a new article or tool now and then.

No more than one email a week. You can unsubscribe anytime, and the Privacy Policy explains how we handle your name and email.

Can't tell a cheap stock from a dying one?

The Bufetico Filter checks more than 30,000 companies against six layers and shows you only the ones that pass. You decide how strict each layer is. Bufetico opens soon.

Join the waitlist »