The headline said record profits, so you bought. A few months later the company was short of cash, and you couldn’t see how both things could be true. Joshua Esnard had to pay the tariff, the tax on imported goods, before he could pick up his own products at the port. He runs The Cut Buddy, a grooming company in Morrisville, North Carolina. Almost everything it sells is made in China, and many of its products sell at Walmart and Target. One day in May 2025, he paid a $4,636 tariff on a shipment of replacement shaver heads worth $3,040, NPR reported. The tariff was bigger than the shaver heads were worth. “You’re stuck in this situation when you’re desperate, and customs has your product at the dock,” he told NPR.
His tariff bills for 2025 came to roughly $800,000, more than five times what he’d normally budget. He covered them with three merchant cash advances. That’s fast money the lender takes back as a daily or weekly cut of sales. In sales, 2025 was the company’s best year. But the tariffs and the debt payments ate all the profits, NPR reported.
What each line counts
Profit and cash can disagree about the same year, and most of the gap is timing. When an importer pays a tariff, the cash is gone the day the boxes land. But on the income statement, that cost waits. Accounting adds the tariff to what the goods cost, and the goods sit as inventory until they sell. Profit is built on accruals. Those are entries that record a sale and its cost when the goods change hands, whether or not any money has moved yet. Cash from operations only counts the money that came in and went out.
Simpson Manufacturing shows the same gap on a much bigger scale. It makes the steel connectors and fasteners that hold wooden houses together. Its 10-K, the annual report for 2025, says tariff changes on some imported fasteners and anchors pushed up its costs that year. But the year that shows the gap best is 2021. That year, Simpson’s profit, its net income, was $266.4 million, 42% more than in 2020. The cash its operations brought in was $151.3 million, 27% less.
The cash flow statement walks you from one number to the other. It starts with the $266.4 million of profit and adds back $71.3 million of charges that used no cash that year, like depreciation, the cost of wear on machines and buildings. Then it subtracts $186.5 million that went into operating assets and liabilities, the money tied up in the day-to-day business. Most of that was $164.2 million more inventory and $68.0 million more that customers owed. Going the other way, Simpson had $50.5 million of costs it had recorded but hadn’t paid yet. What’s left, after rounding, is the $151.3 million.
Where the profit went
Most of it is sitting in inventory. The goods on hand went from $283.7 million at the end of 2020 to $443.8 million at the end of 2021. That’s up 56%, in a year when sales grew 24%. The filing says steel, its main raw material, cost more than in 2020 and more than it had historically. In North America, where it holds the bulk of its inventory, pounds on hand fell 2%. But the average cost per pound of everything it held rose about 63%. So Simpson was holding about the same amount of steel, at a much higher price. Any importer’s tariff works the same way on paper. The money sits in goods on a shelf, and it only shows up in profit when they sell.
And the gap can run the other way. In the first half of 2026, Simpson’s inventory fell from $594.2 million to $513.5 million, and the cash flow statement counts $74.9 million of that as cash freed up. Cash from operations was $248.5 million, more than the $215.3 million of profit. Cash also runs ahead when a company owes its suppliers more, as I found in the payables line of Builders FirstSource.
I went through Simpson’s profit and cash year by year in the case study.
Where this breaks
Any single year of cash can be a year of stocking up or of drawing down, and the number alone won’t tell you which. In the twelve years up to 2025, Simpson’s net income fell only once. So a test that only asks whether earnings fell would have called Simpson financially stable in 2021, the same year its cash dropped by more than a quarter. That’s why I read cash over a run of years and watch how it moves from year to year. If you measure growth from or to one of those unusual years, the number mostly tells you what happened to inventory.
Buying another company breaks the easy math. In 2022 Simpson bought Etanco, a European fastener maker, and inventory on the balance sheet rose from $443.8 million to $556.8 million. But the operating section of the cash flow statement charges only $28.4 million to inventory. That’s because $107.2 million of inventory came with Etanco, and it was paid for in the investing section. Take the obvious shortcut across thousands of companies, subtracting one balance sheet from the next, and the purchase ends up counted in operations. And a growing pile of inventory can be product nobody is ordering. On the cash flow statement, that looks just like stocking up.
Joshua Esnard’s best year
Esnard’s best sales year ended with him skipping his own paycheck in January. Early this year, a nonprofit lender turned his cash advances into a five-year loan, but the debt was still there. Simpson once had the opposite year. In 2009, its sales were down 22.7% in a weak housing market, and net income fell from $53.9 million to $12.2 million. But cash from operations more than doubled, from $56.1 million to $126.2 million. The inventory line alone handed back $92.6 million.
Key factsThe numbers and where they come from · 18 September 2026
- In 2021, Simpson Manufacturing reported net income of $266.4 million, 42% more than in 2020, while the cash its operations brought in was $151.3 million, 27% less.
- On Simpson’s balance sheet, inventory went from $283.7 million at the end of 2020 to $443.8 million at the end of 2021, up 56% in a year when sales grew 24%.
- In the first half of 2026, Simpson’s inventory fell from $594.2 million to $513.5 million. Its cash flow statement shows cash from operations of $248.5 million, ahead of $215.3 million of profit.
- Joshua Esnard, who runs The Cut Buddy in North Carolina, paid a $4,636 tariff in May 2025 on a shipment of replacement shaver heads worth $3,040, NPR reported.