Bufetico Join the waitlist
Cheap or expensiveCase study

Money that may never come: PepsiCo, an unpaid potato bill, and how future cash becomes a value today

Tom Neumiller was sent to collect a bill for seed potatoes and never got the money. His family has sold potatoes to Frito-Lay, now part of PepsiCo, for more than 70 years. How future cash becomes a value today, with PepsiCo's own cash.
7 October 2026 · · 5 min read

You counted money a company was supposed to make as if it were already in the bank, and it never showed up. The seed potatoes had gone to a farmer in northern Illinois, and the money for them never came. After college, Tom Neumiller went home to his family’s farm in Wisconsin, and his father, Fred, sent him down to collect it. “My dad never did get the money,” his daughter, Katie Neumiller-Floming, told Illinois Farm Bureau Partners in May 2026. He did get a good look at the sandy ground around Savanna, though. Potatoes do well in sandy ground.

Back home, he told his father there was good potato land down in Illinois, if they ever got the chance. In 1974, Katie’s parents bought land in Hanover, in Jo Daviess County, and they still own it. Later the family bought more down the road in Savanna. She says the family has joked for years that it’s a good thing her dad kept his day job as a potato farmer, because he wasn’t much of a money collector.

The potatoes go back further than that. Katie’s great-grandfather grew them in a German community in Russia, fled during the Russian Revolution, and kept growing them in Canada and then in Colorado. In the 1950s, Fred started selling to a chip maker called Red Dot on a handshake. Katie says Red Dot and other companies merged into what became Frito-Lay, and the family has sold to it for more than 70 years. Frito-Lay is part of PepsiCo now. In the lobby of the Savanna office there’s a collection of old potato chip cans and boxes, a lot of them from Midwestern companies. She says they like to think her grandfather grew the potatoes for some of those chips.

In February 2026, Lay’s ran a Super Bowl ad called “Last Harvest,” about a potato farmer passing the farm down to his daughter. PepsiCo said the Neumillers inspired it. The company says more than 160 farms across North America grow the potatoes for Lay’s chips.

Katie is the farm’s operations manager, and she runs its trucking too. More than 40 people work with the family, and some have been there for over 40 years. Everything they grow is under contract, she says. A potato crop takes too much to put in the ground just to haul it to the co-op after harvest. They plant in March, start digging in July, and often keep going into October. The potatoes get sorted, washed and graded, then go on the farm’s own semis to the plants that process them. For a plant less than two hours away, a potato dug at 8 in the morning can be in a bag by 1 in the afternoon.

Let’s say someone owes you a dollar, and you can have it today or after next year’s harvest. You’d take it today. You could buy seed with it, or put it in the bank and get paid a little just for waiting. So a later dollar is worth less to you now, for two reasons: you have to wait for it, and it might never come, like the money for Tom’s seed potatoes. When you put a value on a business from the cash it’ll bring in, it works the same way. A dollar the business brings in years from now counts for less today.

A 2017 tax law put a one-time tax on profits that US companies had kept overseas, and companies could choose to pay it over eight years. The ones that did wouldn’t owe any interest, the Taxpayer Advocate Service wrote in 2018. A bill you can pay years from now, at no extra charge, costs you less today than the same bill paid right away. PepsiCo paid it in pieces, and its annual report says the last payment, $965 million, was due in 2026.

For a company, the dollars you wait on are the cash left over after it pays for the property and equipment it needs. In 2025, PepsiCo’s operations brought in $12,087 million, and it spent $4,415 million on property and equipment. What’s left after that, $7,672 million, is called free cash flow. To account for the wait, my model uses the rate the US government pays to borrow, because PepsiCo reports in dollars. It doesn’t do anything about a customer who never pays.

Where this breaks

Free cash flow doesn’t have one official definition. PepsiCo’s own version adds back what it got from selling property, $528 million in 2025, so its number comes out bigger than mine. And one year doesn’t tell you much. PepsiCo spent $5,318 million on property and equipment in 2024, and $4,415 million in 2025.

A lot of the value also comes from years far in the future, and I went through that with Netflix’s terminal value. I wrote about promised money that hasn’t come in yet with Oracle’s signed contracts.

Tom Neumiller is still on the farm

Katie says her dad is still very much in the business. He’s the first one in every morning and the last one to leave at night.

PepsiCo made its last payment on the tax, $965 million, in the first 24 weeks of 2026, which is close to half its year. But its cash doesn’t come in evenly. In 2025, the same stretch brought in $996 million, out of $12,087 million for the full year. Through mid-June 2026, its operations brought in $2,365 million, with the tax already taken out. Over the same weeks, it paid $4.4 billion to shareholders in dividends and buybacks, and $2.2 billion on long-term debt. The quarterly report says the $4.4 billion and the $2.2 billion were offset by $3.5 billion of net short-term borrowing and $3.0 billion of new long-term debt.

With PepsiCo, I’d only judge the cash over a full year, because just a small part of PepsiCo’s yearly cash comes in during the first 24 weeks. Then I’d see how much of the operating cash is left after PepsiCo pays for property and equipment, and compare that with the dividends and buybacks. If the payouts are bigger than what’s left, I’d read the borrowing lines in the same report to see how PepsiCo covers the difference.

To find out whether PepsiCo looks cheap or expensive today, look it up in Bufetico.

PepsiCo’s cash flow statement counts a dollar only once it’s in the bank.

Key factsThe numbers and where they come from · 7 October 2026
  • In 2025, PepsiCo’s operations brought in $12,087 million and it spent $4,415 million on property and equipment, leaving $7,672 million of free cash flow (PepsiCo’s annual report).
  • PepsiCo’s own version of free cash flow adds back what it got from selling property, $528 million in 2025, so its figure comes out bigger than operating cash minus spending on property and equipment.
  • A 2017 US law put a one-time tax on profits that companies kept overseas, and PepsiCo paid it in installments. Its annual report says the last payment, $965 million, was due in 2026.
  • Through mid-June 2026, with the last tax payment already taken out, PepsiCo’s operations brought in $2,365 million. It paid $4.4 billion to shareholders in dividends and buybacks over the same weeks, its quarterly report says.

Bufetico puts every company on more than 30 exchanges through the same six layers. Prices update after every market close, and company financials once a month. What passes is decided by thresholds you set yourself. See it.

← All articles

Sold too early, or held on too long?

Join the waitlist and I'll email you when Bufetico opens, plus a new article or tool now and then.

No more than one email a week. You can unsubscribe anytime, and the Privacy Policy explains how we handle your name and email.

Can't tell a cheap stock from a dying one?

The Bufetico Filter checks more than 30,000 companies against six layers and shows you only the ones that pass. You decide how strict each layer is. Bufetico opens soon.

Join the waitlist »