The company looks fine and the price drops anyway. It starts to feel like the market is rigged against you. In November 2025, Jon Jaffe told Lennar’s board he was retiring from the homebuilder. He’d started there 42 years earlier as an assistant superintendent in Tampa, and he’d stayed through Hurricane Andrew and the Great Recession. He was leaving as co-CEO and president. Lennar said it had no plans to replace him.
Stuart Miller had been running the company with him. In the announcement, Miller said Jaffe’s retirement and its timing had to do with Lennar’s need to rework how it’s organized and what it costs to run. That way, it could build homes more people can afford. Jaffe said much the same thing about his own exit. With the market the way it was, he said, his leaving let Lennar thin out the leadership at the top.
The houses kept coming. In fiscal 2025, his last full year there, Lennar handed over the keys to about 3 percent more homes than in 2024. But its profit per share, the company’s profit divided by the number of shares, fell 44 percent.
Where the profit went
A good part of the missing profit went to the people buying those houses. The annual report says Lennar gives buyers incentives, mostly price cuts on individual homes and help with the financing. Those come off the revenue it reports. In 2025 they came to $62,700 a home. Its gross margin, what’s left of each dollar from a house once the land and the building are paid for, went from 22.3 percent to 17.7.
Lennar offers those incentives because of who’s walking into its sales offices. On a call with analysts on September 17, Lennar’s executives said almost half of those visitors can’t qualify for a home right away, Bloomberg reported. Lennar said mortgage rates had climbed all summer.
And those buyers have somewhere else to look too. For years, homeowners held on to the cheap mortgages they’d locked in and put off moving. Miller said they’re finally starting to negotiate, above all in Florida and Texas, two of Lennar’s biggest markets. When someone selling their own house cuts the price, he said, “they are competing directly for our customer and we respond.”
Miller laid out the plan in the September release: meet demand at prices people can afford, and keep building through the slow market. The way I read the housing cycle, when mortgages get expensive, sales of new homes usually fall first and house prices fall last. Lennar flips that order on purpose. Its annual report says the company adjusts prices to keep starting and selling homes at a steady pace. And it calls its gross margin the shock absorber.
What the price followed
On September 16, with Miller as the only CEO, Lennar reported the quarter that ended in August. It handed over 3 percent fewer homes than a year earlier and earned $1.19 a share, down from $2.29.
Lennar’s own reports also give you a rough share price: the average it paid when it bought back its own shares. A year earlier that average was $122.97. This time it was $85.49, about 30 percent less. Over the same year, the profit per share fell by almost half, and the number of houses barely moved. So the price went the same way as the profit, but it fell a lot less.
Over time, the profit per share is what makes stock prices go up and down. Each share is a small slice of the company, and owning that slice gives you a claim on its part of the profit. I see three things in a share price. There’s what the business earns, and what people expect it to earn next. And there’s how much they’ll pay today for those later earnings, which is where interest rates and mood come in. Any news gets into the price through one of those three. At Lennar, what the business earned set the direction.
Where this breaks
The buyback figure is an average of what Lennar paid over three months. It’s good enough to show which way the stock went and roughly how far, and not much more. It also stops on August 31, so it misses September 16, when Miller said the quarter’s profit came in below expectations and Lennar lowered its target for the year’s deliveries. The release doesn’t say what those expectations were, and I won’t guess. The price fell less than the profit, so something held it up. People also pay for the years after this one, and no filing shows that part.
Some of the drop in profit has nothing to do with houses, either. Lennar owns stakes in technology companies. Every quarter, it values the ones listed on the stock market at whatever they trade for. So they swing: a gain a year earlier, a loss this time. If you take those and a few one-time items out, as the company does, the drop is smaller but goes the same way. A homebuilder’s profit also rides the housing cycle. That’s why dividing the price by one year of profit says little about it. And telling the cycle apart from a real decline takes more than one year of numbers.
Jaffe’s last September
In September 2025, Jaffe was the one who reported how fast Lennar was building. It was putting up a home in 126 days, its fastest ever, and he gave part of the credit to its talks with the firms it builds with. In September 2026, the record was 116 days. And the cost of building a square foot kept coming down, 6 percent in a year. Lennar credits that to keeping the number of homes steady. The share price didn’t follow that number.
Lennar also spent more on marketing and selling in the quarter. Some of what went to the buyers came out of the savings on building. Whatever those savings didn’t cover came out of the shareholders’ profit.
Let’s say I owned Lennar. I’d leave the daily price alone and open each quarterly release. I’d put the homes delivered and the profit per share side by side, each against the same quarter a year earlier. In the annual report, I’d look at the incentives per home and the gross margin, to see how much of the profit went to the buyers.
I run every company through the same six layers. To see where Lennar stands on them today, look it up in Bufetico.
If Lennar’s price falls while the company looks fine, look at the profit per share before you decide the market is rigged against you.
Key factsThe numbers and where they come from · 20 September 2026
- In fiscal 2025, which ended November 30, 2025, Lennar delivered about 3 percent more homes than in 2024, while its profit per share fell 44 percent (Lennar’s annual report).
- Lennar’s incentives to buyers, mostly price cuts on individual homes and help with financing, came to $62,700 a home in 2025. Its gross margin went from 22.3 percent to 17.7 that year, the annual report says.
- For the quarter that ended in August 2026, Lennar earned $1.19 a share, down from $2.29 a year earlier, and delivered fewer homes (Lennar’s September release).
- Lennar reported in September 2026 that it was building a home in 116 days, a company record, against 126 days a year earlier, and that its cost of building a square foot fell 6 percent in a year.
