Only if the business is still the one it was. An average P/E is what the market used to pay. Using it assumes that level was right and that nothing important has changed. I find it more useful to ask what profit today’s price needs the company to make, and whether that looks doable.
Someone asked on Reddit when TJX, the company behind T.J. Maxx and Marshalls, would trade back near its old average. I’d question the average before the price. If the business has changed for good, waiting for the old multiple can mean waiting forever. And if the old multiple was generous to begin with, it isn’t a floor either.
TJX has changed. In fiscal 2020, the year that ended February 1, 2020, it kept 10.6 cents of pretax profit from every dollar of sales and earned $2.67 a share, according to its annual report for that year. In fiscal 2026, the year that ended January 31, 2026, it kept 12.1 cents and earned $4.87 a share on $60.4 billion of sales, per the annual report for fiscal 2026. The old average was paying for a company that kept less of each dollar.
The average can also be bent by one strange year. In fiscal 2021, with stores shut for part of the pandemic, TJX earned 7 cents a share, as its 2021 annual report shows. Divide the price by 7 cents and you get a P/E in the hundreds, and any average that includes that year gets pulled with it.
So I start with the business: what it earns now, how steady that’s been, and what it would have to earn for today’s price to make sense, and the filings answer all three.
Where this breaks
Asking what profit the price needs has a weak spot too: the answer depends on what you assume about the years ahead. So write those assumptions down when you buy, and check them against the annual reports later.