Bufetico Join the waitlist

When does a buyback actually create value?

Published 9 October 2026 ·

A buyback helps the shareholders who stay only when the company pays less for its shares than the business is worth. If it pays more, value moves from the owners who stay to the ones who sell. So when a company sends all its spare cash to buybacks, one judgment about price ends up carrying the whole plan.

GoDaddy did exactly that in 2025. Its cash from operations minus capital spending went from $635.8 million in 2019, in its 2019 annual report, to $1,575.5 million in 2025. That same year it spent $1,601.9 million buying back its own stock, according to the 2025 annual report. That’s all of the cash and a bit more.

The debt didn’t move much. Long-term debt was $3,765.2 million at the end of 2025, against $3,812.9 million three years earlier. And with that much going out, the equity is close to nothing: $6.7 million at the end of June 2026, on $8.0 billion of assets, in the second-quarter report. The average diluted share count went from 151.5 million in 2023 to 131.0 million in the June 2026 quarter.

Plenty of good businesses run with equity near or below zero. What stands out is that buybacks are the whole plan here. GoDaddy isn’t paying down debt and has never paid a dividend, so the shareholders who stayed are counting on the prices it paid for its own shares.

Where this breaks

Some buybacks only make up for shares handed out as pay, so the money goes out and the share count barely moves. That’s why I read the share count next to the dollars spent.

First answered on Reddit, 16 September 2026.

← All questions

Sold too early, or held on too long?

Join the waitlist and I'll email you when Bufetico opens, plus a new article or tool now and then.

No more than one email a week. You can unsubscribe anytime, and the Privacy Policy explains how we handle your name and email.

Can't tell a cheap stock from a dying one?

The Bufetico Filter checks more than 30,000 companies against six layers and shows you only the ones that pass. You decide how strict each layer is. Bufetico opens soon.

Join the waitlist »