Because the bad case usually gets built from recent years, and in a lot of cyclicals the recent years were the boom. Before I trust a downside, I set it next to the last ordinary years, when the industry was neither booming nor broken. If the bad case sits above those, it’s a smaller boom.
Simpson’s margin, before and after
Simpson Manufacturing sells steel connectors and fasteners for house building. Its operating margin, what’s left of each dollar of sales after running the business, was 16.0% in 2018 and 15.9% in 2019, from its 2019 annual report. Then housing took off. From 2020 to 2025 the margin stayed between 19.3% and 23.3%, with the top in 2021, according to its annual reports for 2022 and 2025.
Let’s say you write down 18% as the bad case. That’s above both of the last two years before the pandemic, so the whole range sits above the ordinary years and the low end is the boom with a little taken off.
The same thing one line down
Net margin, what’s left after interest and taxes, moved the same way. It was 11.8% in 2019 and 14.8% in 2025, from the same annual reports. Put the same sales at 2019’s net margin instead of 2025’s and the profit comes out about 20% lower. So the margin you pick can matter more than the sales forecast.
Where this breaks
The company in 2018 isn’t exactly the company today, and ordinary years from before a big change may not describe it. When that’s the case, write down which margin sits behind each case. Then you can see which assumption you’re making.