Because the P/E uses net income, after tax, and one tax item can make that profit far bigger than what the business earned. When a company decides old tax assets, like past losses, are usable, its tax line turns into a gain. Then the P/E looks low, and the business had nothing to do with it.
Uber had one of these. In the quarter that ended in September 2025, its net income was $6,626 million and its tax line was minus $4,046 million, meaning tax added to profit instead of taking from it, says its third-quarter report. The report explains it: Uber released $4.9 billion of the valuation allowance on its deferred tax assets in the Netherlands. Operating income that quarter was $1,113 million.
That one quarter stays in any P/E built on the last four reported quarters until the next report comes out. Add the quarter to 2025’s fourth quarter and the first two of 2026, through the June quarter, and you get $9,579 million of net income. About 69 percent of it comes from that September quarter.
GoDaddy did the same thing in 2023. Net income was $1,374.8 million, and inside it was a $971.8 million tax benefit, mostly from releasing $1,014.0 million of its domestic valuation allowance, according to its 2023 annual report. Operating income that year was $547.4 million.
So before I lean on a P/E, I put net income next to operating income. When net income is bigger, I read the tax note to find out why. Then I run the same comparison on operating cash flow.
Where this breaks
A tax benefit like this has something real behind it. It can lower future tax bills in cash, as long as the company earns enough to use it, and that happens over years. And when that quarter drops out of the last four, the P/E jumps even though nothing changed in the business.