You can’t value one year of a cyclical company, so I don’t try. I take the cash its operations produced across a whole cycle, good years and bad, and I work from that. Then I check whether the company can sit through the bottom without having its hand forced. That part matters more.
Why one year doesn’t work
In a cyclical, the year you pick decides the answer. Pick the top and the business looks huge. Pick the bottom and it looks broken.
The profit line can hide the cycle from you, too. At Simpson Manufacturing, which makes steel connectors for house building, profit went up in 2021 and the cash from operations went down 27%, according to its 2021 annual report. So I read the cash, over the whole stretch, the way I go through in why profit and cash disagree.
Can it wait?
If a cyclical runs out of room, somebody else starts making its decisions, usually the lenders. So I look at what goes out against what comes in while it’s at the bottom.
Builders FirstSource, which sells lumber and trusses to home builders, spent $303.5 million buying back its own shares in the first six months of 2026, about twice what its operations brought in, its 10-Q for the June quarter shows. The cycle may still turn. That spending tells you how much of the wait the company can pay for.
Where this breaks
An average only covers the cycles that are in your data. If the years in your data never went through a real housing bust, averaging them won’t put one in.