Because the years they disagree tell you something neither line says alone. Profit counts a sale when the goods go out, and cash counts it when the money comes in. When the two split, something on the balance sheet is soaking up the difference, and in a cyclical that’s often where the cycle shows up.
Simpson in 2021
Simpson Manufacturing makes steel connectors and fasteners for house building. In 2021 its net income went from $187.0 million to $266.4 million, up 42%. Its cash from operations went from $207.6 million to $151.3 million, down 27%. Inventory went from $283.7 million to $443.8 million. It’s all in its 2021 annual report, which also says the pounds of steel it held in North America went down 2% while the average cost per pound went up about 63%.
Sales were fine. The company paid a lot more for about the same amount of steel, and a big part of that year’s profit was sitting in inventory. The next year the cash came back, to $399.8 million, its 2022 annual report shows.
Read only the profit line and 2021 looks like a great year. Read only the cash and it looks like the business got worse.
One good cash year isn’t a new level
It runs the other way too. When a company empties its shelves, cash comes in ahead of profit for a while. That happens once. I don’t treat it as the new normal until the cash holds there without the inventory coming down.
Where this breaks
Cash can be pushed around too. A company that pays its suppliers later gets a better cash line for a season, the way Builders FirstSource did in early 2026.