Bufetico Join the waitlist

You clicked buy at one price and paid another: how a stock exchange works, from SpaceX's first trade

· 4 min read

Course contents

You’ve clicked buy at one price and the order filled at another, and you never found out why. Justin Sacco, who founded a firm called Sacco Financial, asked Charles Schwab for 75 shares of SpaceX before the company went public, and he got 11. He’d been a Schwab client for a long time and hoped that would help, CNBC reported on June 12, the first day SpaceX traded. Once trading started, he bought four more shares on the open market, so he ended up with 15.

In his account, all 15 shares look the same. But he got them in two different markets, and the money went to two different places.

Two markets for the same share

The first 11 came from SpaceX itself. In an initial public offering, or IPO, the company sells brand new shares and keeps the money. SpaceX sold 638.9 million Class A shares at $135 each, counting the extra shares the banks running the sale had the right to buy. It kept $85,675 million after commissions and costs, its quarterly report says. The prospectus, the document a company files to sell its shares, says part of the offering went out through brokers like Schwab, Fidelity, Robinhood and SoFi, at the same price and at the same time as the big funds. When orders add up to more than the shares on offer, many get filled only in part. That’s how 75 turned into 11.

The other four came from somebody who already owned SpaceX shares and wanted to sell, so the money for those went to that seller. This second market is the stock exchange. It’s where owners trade with each other, after the company has already been paid. SpaceX listed its shares on two exchanges, Nasdaq and Nasdaq Texas, under the symbol SPCX.

How an exchange matches buyers and sellers

An exchange keeps a book of orders, a running list of the people who want to buy or sell. Every buyer says how many shares they want and the most they’ll pay. Every seller says how many they’ll sell and the least they’ll take. An order with a price on it is called a limit order. An order that takes the best price available right now is a market order. When a buyer’s price meets a seller’s, the exchange matches them, and that trade becomes the price you see on your screen. Between trades, the price just sits there.

On a normal day, that matching runs from 9:30 in the morning to 4:00 in the afternoon, New York time. But the first trade of a brand new stock works differently. It has never traded, so there’s no last price to start from. Instead, the exchange collects orders first and looks for the one price where the most shares can change hands.

On SpaceX’s first day, trading desks were first shown a price around $175. As the orders came in, it slid toward $150. Nelson Griggs, Nasdaq’s president, told CNBC how it usually goes for a deal that size. The bank in charge of steadying the price wants orders for about 10% of the shares sold before it sets the opening price. Here, that came to roughly 55 million shares. SpaceX’s first trade finally came more than two hours after the market opened: 58 million shares changed hands at $150. By the end of the day, more than 500 million shares had changed hands.

That bank was Morgan Stanley. The prospectus lets the banks buy shares on the open market after the offering to hold the price up, and it says they can stop at any time. So for a while, some of the buying in the book can come from the banks that ran the offering.

Where this breaks

The price on your screen is only the last trade. If nobody trades a stock, its price stays where it was, no matter what happens to the business. Bufetico, the screener I built, once carried prices for 4,041 companies that had stopped trading, and they sat at the top of the list.

And there’s someone between you and the exchange. You don’t send an order to Nasdaq yourself. Your broker sends it for you. On SpaceX’s first day, Robinhood told CNBC that record traffic left some customers with delays and problems that came and went. When your broker is slow, the book can move before your order even gets there.

When one company trades on exchanges in two countries, it has two prices. I walked through that in one TSMC vice president, one day, two prices. And if you want to know what each number on the screen means, I go through them in how to read a stock quote.

When Sacco can sell

Sacco can sell his 15 shares any day the market is open. Most of SpaceX can’t be sold yet. The prospectus locks up about 7.8 billion shares for more than a year, so their owners can’t sell them until then. That’s around 60% of all the shares outstanding after the offering, and it includes every share owned by Elon Musk, the founder. The rest of the shares that owners held before the IPO come free in steps: up to another 7% on October 24, up to another 28% after SpaceX reports its results for the September quarter, and all of them on December 8, 2026.

Key factsThe numbers and where they come from · 10 October 2026
  • In its June 2026 IPO, SpaceX sold 638.9 million Class A shares at $135 each, counting the extra shares its banks had an option to buy, and kept $85,675 million after commissions and costs, its quarterly report says.
  • SpaceX opened at $150 on 58 million shares on June 12, 2026, more than two hours into the trading day, and more than 500 million shares changed hands by the close, CNBC reported.
  • On SpaceX’s first day, Nelson Griggs, Nasdaq’s president, told CNBC that for a deal that size, the bank steadying the price usually wants orders for about 10% of the shares sold before it sets the opening price.
  • About 7.8 billion SpaceX shares, around 60% of all the shares outstanding after the June 2026 offering, are locked up for more than a year under the prospectus, including every share Elon Musk owns.

Sold too early, or held on too long?

Join the waitlist and I'll email you when Bufetico opens, plus a new article or tool now and then.

No more than one email a week. You can unsubscribe anytime, and the Privacy Policy explains how we handle your name and email.

Can't tell a cheap stock from a dying one?

The Bufetico Filter checks more than 30,000 companies against six layers and shows you only the ones that pass. You decide how strict each layer is. Bufetico opens soon.

Join the waitlist »