You picked stocks by feel, and you moved your own rules every time the list didn’t look the way you wanted. On the first Saturday of December 2025, Notre Dame’s football players had nothing to do but wait. They’d won ten games in a row, but Notre Dame doesn’t play in a conference, so there was no title game for them. Every ranking the College Football Playoff committee put out that fall had them in the top 10. Then the final one came out on Sunday, December 7, and they were 11th, the first team left out of the 12-team field, NBC News reported.
Miami got the last spot. Both teams finished 10-2, and Miami had beaten Notre Dame 27-24 in the first week of the season. Hunter Yurachek, who chairs the committee, had said that win wasn’t a big factor. Then BYU lost its conference final that Saturday and dropped in the last ranking. Miami moved up, and the two teams ended up right next to each other. At that point, the game from the first week decided it. The committee had watched it again. “It just felt like there was a little bit more athleticism on the side of Miami versus Notre Dame,” Yurachek said.
What the committee wrote down
The committee has written rules. Its protocol says that to separate teams that are otherwise comparable, it looks at strength of schedule, meaning how tough their opponents were. It also looks at head-to-head results, results against common opponents and other things, like key players or coaches who were out. And it says no single metric will decide it. So the list tells you what counts. But it doesn’t tell you how much each thing counts. The members decide that part themselves.
A stock screener, a tool that filters companies by the numbers you choose, makes you do that part on paper, before you see anything. What a stock screener is covers the basics. Every line you set has two parts: the measure, and where you draw it. Let’s say you care about three things. The company owes less than two years of its cash from operations. Its sales are higher than they were three years ago. And it keeps at least 10 cents of every dollar of sales as operating profit. The screener checks every company it covers and shows you the ones that clear all three.
Decide how much before you look
The “how much” is where you put the line. A tight line says that measure matters a lot to you. A loose one says it matters a little. When you set up a screen, you’re doing the committee’s weighing before you know who’ll show up.
Write your lines down before you run the screen: the measure, where you drew it, the date, and one sentence on why. Once you see the list, every line starts bending toward the companies you already like. You’ll catch yourself loosening the debt line because a name you know missed it by a little.
Move the line on purpose
Lines are supposed to move, and there are two good reasons to move one. Maybe you learned something about the measure itself, like a whole type of business where that number means something else. Or the list came back empty, or with thousands of names. Then you loosen or tighten one line at a time and watch who comes in and who drops out.
There’s also one bad reason, and it’s the common one: a company you like didn’t make it. Would you move this line if you didn’t know which company was sitting just under it? If the answer depends on the name, leave the line where it is. When you do move one, write down the old line, the new one, the date and why. A year later, you can check whether the move did what you said it would.
Bufetico, the screener I built, works the same way. You set the line on each of its six layers, which together make the Bufetico Filter, and it hands back the companies that clear all six. The six layers tell you three things: if the company is cheap or expensive, if it’s financially stable, and if it’s growing.
Where this breaks
A line is blunt. A company that misses it by a hair is gone, same as one that misses it by a mile. The committee keeps room for “other relevant factors.” A screen doesn’t, so you still have to read what comes back.
You can at least check a line you wrote down against what the companies did later. That’s the same reason to write down what you think before you put money in.
What changed for Notre Dame
Within hours, the team pulled out of the running for a bowl game and said it hoped to bring a 12th national title to South Bend in 2026. This season, the playoff’s format has a line for Notre Dame written in advance. It gets an automatic bid, a place in the playoff, if it’s ranked in the committee’s top 12 on Selection Day. That rule wasn’t there last December, when the committee ranked Notre Dame 11th.
Key factsThe numbers and where they come from · 10 October 2026
- In the College Football Playoff committee’s final ranking on December 7, 2025, Notre Dame was 11th, the first team left out of the 12-team field, NBC News reported.
- Miami got the last spot. Both teams finished 10-2, and Miami had beaten Notre Dame 27-24 in the first week of the 2025 season, NBC News reported.
- The selection committee’s protocol separates comparable teams by strength of schedule, head-to-head results, results against common opponents and other factors, and says there will be no single metric.
- For the 2026 season, the playoff’s format gives Notre Dame an automatic bid if the committee ranks it in its top 12 on Selection Day.