You saw a low P/E and figured you’d found a bargain. Then you watched the price keep sliding, without knowing what that number was telling you. Brittany Gilroy is 35, and so is her husband, Phillip West. They rent a red brick, two-story house in Richmond, Virginia, and share it with their dog, Basil, and a roommate. They moved in with a friend thinking it would be for a few months, until they bought a house. That was nearly four years ago, NPR reported in July. Gilroy wants children only if they can settle down in a safe neighborhood with good schools, and that costs more. “There is no kiddie pool of a starter home,” she told NPR.
Every house they look at has a price. A house like the one they rent also has a rent. Divide the price by a year of rent and you get a multiple: how many years of rent the price adds up to. Let’s say a house costs $300,000 and rents for $25,000 a year. The price is 12 years of rent. A P/E ratio does the same math for a company.
What the ratio divides
P is the price of one share. E is the company’s profit for one year divided by the number of shares, and the income statement calls it earnings per share. You can also do it for the whole company, its market value over its profit for the year, and you get the same answer. A P/E of 12 means you’re paying 12 years of this year’s profit.
A family buying a house knows the rent won’t stay flat forever, and an investor buying a company knows this year’s profit won’t either. So every multiple has a guess built in about the years ahead. When the multiple is high, buyers expect more profit later, or they think this year’s profit is unusually low. A low one can mean buyers expect less, or this year was unusually good. The ratio doesn’t tell you which, and that’s why you go to the company’s reports.
Gilroy and West have been making that same guess, as renters. Gilroy told NPR that every time they looked at a house, it came down to whether they wanted to empty their savings to get it. They said no, and then prices went up. West said buying a home is part of deciding whether to have kids at all. When house prices climb and rents don’t keep up, the multiple gets bigger, even if nothing about the house has changed.
A landlord’s P/E
Invitation Homes rents out single-family houses across the country. At the end of 2025 it owned 86,192 of them outright, its annual report says. Its diluted earnings per share for that year, the version that also counts shares it may still have to issue, were $0.96.
For P, you need a share price from a given day. On July 31, the company held back shares from one of its executives to cover his taxes. The Form 4 filed for him values each share at $29.72, the closing price that day. An insider files that form when their stake changes. Divide $29.72 by $0.96 and you get about 31. So a share that day cost about 31 years of 2025 profit.
Now look at how E moved. Earnings per share were $0.85 in 2023, $0.74 in 2024 and $0.96 in 2025, up about 30 percent in one year. Rent and other property income grew only 3.6 percent that year. In 2024, a line called “casualty losses, impairment and other” cost the company $82.9 million, and $55.1 million of that was damage from four hurricanes. In 2025 the same line was $11.4 million. Part of the jump in profit came from a bad year dropping out, and the P/E moved with it.
Where this breaks
A landlord has a cost most companies don’t have at this size. Invitation Homes charged $746.9 million of depreciation and amortization in 2025, more than its whole profit. That charge is a slice of what it paid for its houses and other assets, spread over the years they’re expected to last. The accounts wear the houses down a little every year, whatever happens to the price of the house next door. That’s why real estate companies report other measures next to net income, and why a P/E on one can mislead you either way.
And when you run the ratio across thousands of companies, it falls apart at the edges. A company that lost money has no P/E at all. One that barely made a profit gets a P/E in the hundreds. And the lowest P/Es on the list often belong to companies whose profit got a lift that year from something outside the business, like a tax benefit or a sale.
Renters like Gilroy and West
In 2025 Invitation Homes sold 1,356 houses. One way it sells them is a program called Resident First Look, which offers homes to the people already renting them. That’s the step Gilroy and West have been trying to take for nearly four years, going from renting a house to owning one. The gain from all 1,356 sales was $218.2 million after tax, and it sits inside the $589.9 million of profit the company made that year. So 37 cents of every dollar of profit behind that P/E came from selling houses. In 2024, the gain from house sales was more than half.
The two cases go further: a P/E on a company whose profit swings with memory prices, and one price divided by two different years at Nvidia.
Key factsThe numbers and where they come from · 10 October 2026
- At the end of 2025, Invitation Homes owned 86,192 single-family houses outright, and its diluted earnings per share for 2025 were $0.96 (Invitation Homes’ annual report).
- A Form 4 filed for one of Invitation Homes’ executives values each share at $29.72, the closing price on July 31, 2026. That price over 2025 earnings per share gives a P/E of about 31.
- In 2024, Invitation Homes’ line for casualty losses, impairment and other came to $82.9 million, $55.1 million of it for damage from four hurricanes. In 2025 that line was $11.4 million, the annual report shows.
- Sales of 1,356 houses in 2025 brought Invitation Homes a gain of $218.2 million after tax, part of the $589.9 million of profit it made that year, its annual report shows.