Bufetico Join the waitlist

Why your stock fell the same day the company put out great news

· 4 min read

Course contents

The company put out great news, the stock fell the same day, and you sat there feeling like the market was laughing at you. In March, Shantanu Narayen wrote to Adobe’s employees that he’d step down as chief executive once the board found someone to replace him. He joined the company in 1998 and had run it since December 2007. “Adobe has never waited for the future to arrive,” he wrote in that memo, Fortune reported.

On June 11, Adobe reported record revenue. It brought in $6.62 billion in the quarter that ended May 29, 13% more than a year earlier. It also raised its revenue forecast for the year to between $26.5 billion and $26.6 billion, its earnings release says. But the same release said Dan Durn, its chief financial officer, or CFO, was leaving four days later. Marvell, a chipmaker, named him its new CFO on June 11.

Adobe’s shares fell 5% in trading after the market closed, Reuters reported. They were already down more than 37% for the year, because people were afraid AI would eat into what software companies sell, CNBC reported the next morning. Figma and Canva, two of Adobe’s rivals, had already put AI into their own design apps. The business itself was the same that evening as it had been that afternoon.

Inside a share price

Owning a share means owning a small piece of the company. That gives you a claim on part of whatever the business earns, this year and every year after. The price you see is what the last buyer and the last seller agreed on, and it changes with every new trade.

Three things go into that price: what the business earns now, what people think it’ll earn later, and how much they’ll pay today for money that only shows up years from now. That last one is where interest rates and the general mood come in. When rates go up, money that arrives years from now is worth less today. So the same company can trade at a lower price even when nothing else has changed.

What the business earns now is the easy part, because the company reports it. Earnings per share is the profit divided by the number of shares. For Adobe’s quarter, profit was $1.71 billion and earnings per share was $4.25. The release also gives a second figure, $5.96, an adjusted version Adobe calculates itself by leaving out some costs. When a headline says a company beat estimates, meaning it did better than analysts expected, check which of the two numbers the headline is talking about.

On June 11, the news was about the second part, what people think Adobe will earn later. The forecast went up, and that should help. But somebody has to deliver that forecast, and now Adobe was looking for a new chief executive and a new CFO at the same time. The price moves on the difference between what people expected and what they got, and who runs the company is part of what they expect.

Days and years

Over a few days, the price follows expectations and mood. Chipotle is a good example. Its shares jumped on a good quarter and fell on a salmonella outbreak, and none of the reported numbers had changed in between. Over years, the price tends to follow what the business earns per share. At Lennar, the homebuilder, profit per share fell by almost half in a year, and the price went down with it, though not as far.

I don’t watch the daily price. My screener reads what companies report each quarter, and on June 11 Adobe’s report showed record revenue. It can follow whether earnings per share keep growing over several years, and whether the cash comes in to back them up. There’s more on what goes into earnings per share.

Where this breaks

You can’t split a 5% drop into those three things. Reuters tied it to the departing CFO. The next morning, analysts quoted by CNBC also pointed to a lower outlook for recurring revenue, the money customers pay again and again, like subscriptions. The fear about AI tools was still there that evening too. And rates and mood move every stock at once. If someone explains one day’s price with one cause, they’re guessing.

The two versions of earnings per share can be far apart. In that quarter, the reported figure included a charge of $0.17 a share, because Adobe cut the value of one of its units, Publishing & Advertising, on its books. No cash left the company for it. And a change of leaders never shows up as a line in the income statement, the page with sales, costs and profit. A screener only sees a new boss later, if the change ever reaches the numbers.

Narayen’s successor

In September, Adobe named Anil Chakravarthy its next chief executive, starting December 1. He runs its Customer Experience Orchestration business. Narayen becomes executive chair, the head of the board. The board picked Chakravarthy on September 2. That same day, David Wadhwani, president of the Creativity & Productivity business, told Adobe he was stepping down from that job, Adobe’s filing says.

Back in July, Adobe filed a short 8-K about Louise Pentland, its chief legal officer. An 8-K is the form companies use to report big news to investors. If Adobe lets her go without cause, or she leaves for what her retention letter calls good reason, she gets a year of salary, her target bonus and part of her stock awards early. Those protections end 12 months after the new chief executive starts.

Key factsThe numbers and where they come from · 10 October 2026
  • On June 11, 2026, Adobe reported record revenue of $6.62 billion for the three months to May 29, up 13% from a year earlier (Adobe’s earnings release).
  • Adobe’s profit for that quarter was $1.71 billion, or $4.25 a share. The release also prints $5.96 a share, an adjusted figure Adobe calculates itself by leaving out some costs.
  • Adobe’s quarterly earnings release also said Dan Durn, its chief financial officer, was leaving. Marvell announced him as its CFO the same day.
  • In September 2026, Adobe named Anil Chakravarthy its next chief executive, starting December 1, its filing says. Shantanu Narayen, who has run Adobe since December 2007, becomes executive chair.

Sold too early, or held on too long?

Join the waitlist and I'll email you when Bufetico opens, plus a new article or tool now and then.

No more than one email a week. You can unsubscribe anytime, and the Privacy Policy explains how we handle your name and email.

Can't tell a cheap stock from a dying one?

The Bufetico Filter checks more than 30,000 companies against six layers and shows you only the ones that pass. You decide how strict each layer is. Bufetico opens soon.

Join the waitlist »