You let a tool pick, and only found out later what it missed. Derek Mobley says that since 2017, he’s applied for more than 100 jobs at companies that use Workday’s hiring software. He was turned down for every one of them, some within hours. Mobley is Black, over 40 and has a disability. He sued Workday in 2023. In September, his lawyers asked a federal judge in San Francisco to let the case go ahead as a class action, Reuters reported. Workday denies doing anything wrong and has said in court that its customers can “enable, disable, use, or ignore” its features. None of his claims has been proven, and a hearing on the class action is set for March 2027.
One of the tools in the case, the court record says, is a feature called Candidate Skills Match. When an employer turns it on, it reads the job posting and the applicant’s résumé, pulls the skills out of both, and reports how well they match: strong, good, fair, low, pending, or unable to score. In a filing quoted in the judge’s May 2025 order, Workday said that “1.1 billion applications were rejected using Workday” over the years the case covers.
What a screen can answer
At that size, no recruiter reads everything first, and no investor reads every report first either. A screen is good at yes-or-no questions. Did sales grow last year? Is the debt bigger than the cash? Each answer comes from numbers the company already reported.
It’s also good at “compared to what.” Take one company’s margin, the profit it keeps from each dollar of sales. Put it next to the margin of every other company in the same line of business, and you see where it stands. You can’t hold thousands of margins in your head. A screen does it for all of them, every day.
What it cannot answer
A screen only knows what’s already in the reports, and that leaves three kinds of questions it can’t touch. It can’t tell you why a number moved. A jump in profit looks the same whether it came from selling more or from selling a factory. Or whether that jump will happen again, because the report only says it happened once. And anything that happened after the last report, like a lawsuit, a lost customer or a new boss, isn’t there at all. Those reach the numbers months later, if they ever do.
A screen also can’t show you what it threw out. An applicant like Mobley gets the “no.” The court record says the match result goes to the employer. With a stock screen, you’re the employer, and you don’t even get a match result. A company that missed a single bar in a single bad year never reaches you, and nothing tells you it came close.
Then there’s “unable to score.” Every screen runs into companies it can’t measure. One might be too new to have much history. Another might report in a currency with no usable exchange rate. Or it might be a bank, where most of the cash moving through belongs to its customers. I wrote about why cash flow can’t value a bank back in September. Somebody decided what happens to those, and it’s worth asking who and how.
Bufetico, the screener I built, has its own “unable to score.” In the Bufetico Filter, you set the bar on each of the six layers: two tell you if a company is cheap or expensive, three if it’s financially stable, and one if it’s growing. Anything it can’t measure stays gray and never gets estimated, and a gray square keeps the company off the list. The cost is that you have to find some good companies yourself.
Where this breaks
Two people with different bars get two different lists from the same companies. So set your bars on what you’d really act on.
The bigger risk is trusting the list more than it deserves. When a company passes every check, all that tells you is that its past numbers look the way you asked. You still have to open the reports. In the UnitedHealth case, the numbers caught up with the news months later. And the Novo Nordisk case goes through what no column in a screen can see.
What Workday tells investors about Mobley’s case
Workday’s latest quarterly report, for the three months through July, mentions the case in its risk factors, the section where a company lists what could hurt it. It’s an easy part to skip. It says Workday is defending a lawsuit that claims some of its AI products “enable discrimination.” Workday believes the claims lack merit, and “the majority of the claims have been dismissed.” The report also warns that the plaintiff may try to sue some of Workday’s customers, the employers themselves.
Key factsThe numbers and where they come from · 10 October 2026
- Derek Mobley sued Workday in 2023, and in September 2026 his lawyers asked a federal judge to let the case go ahead as a class action, with a hearing set for March 2027, Reuters reported.
- Workday’s Candidate Skills Match, when an employer turns it on, pulls the skills from the job posting and the résumé and rates the match strong, good, fair, low, pending or unable to score, the court record says.
- In a filing quoted in the judge’s May 2025 order, Workday said 1.1 billion applications were rejected using Workday over the years the case covers.
- Workday’s quarterly report for the three months through July 2026 says it believes the claims lack merit and that the majority of them have been dismissed.