Bufetico Join the waitlist

The ratios looked fine and the company was dying: when a ratio stops meaning anything

· 4 min read

Course contents

You checked the ratios and nothing looked scary. Then you found out, too late, that the company was running out of money. Wes Egan spent about 23 years as a dispatcher at Spirit Airlines. Dispatchers plan each flight from the ground and stay in touch with the pilots. On Spirit’s last Friday night, he was working in the operations center in Orlando. At about 11:30 p.m., senior managers told the staff there that Spirit was about to stop flying. When one of the airline’s pilots asked what was going to happen, Egan answered him through the system that sends messages to the cockpit: unofficially, no more flying after 3 a.m. Eastern on May 2. And he added, “Godspeed my friend.”

Spirit shut down at 3 a.m. that Saturday. Its bondholders, the investors who had lent it money, had said no to a bailout plan from the Trump administration, CNBC reported the same day. The airline said about 17,000 people lost their jobs, counting direct and indirect employees. It had filed for bankruptcy for the second time in August, and its last profitable year was 2019.

Spirit filed its last annual report in March. At the end of 2025, its shareholders’ equity was minus $2,091.7 million.

What negative equity means

On its books, equity is what a company owns minus what it owes. It’s what belongs to the shareholders. When it’s negative, the books say the company owes more than it owns. As a shareholder, you don’t owe anyone that minus sign. The debts are on their own lines, further up the balance sheet.

Two very different stories can put a company there, and the equity section of the balance sheet usually tells you which one. Look at two lines. Retained earnings is all the profit the company has kept since it started, after its losses and the dividends it paid. When that number is below zero, some companies call it a deficit. Treasury stock is what the company paid for its own shares that it bought back and still holds.

Spirit had a retained deficit of $2,832.7 million at the end of 2025, and no treasury stock at all. Losses did that.

McDonald’s also ended 2025 below zero, with equity of minus $1,791 million, according to its annual report. But its retained earnings were a positive $70,282 million, and its treasury stock, the shares it had bought back over the years, was on its books at $79,316 million. McDonald’s kept a lot of profit and spent even more than that buying back its own shares.

The ratios that break

Once equity is below zero, any ratio that divides by it stops meaning anything. But the math still hands you a number.

Debt to equity is debt divided by equity, and it’s the usual way to measure how much a company owes. With negative equity, it comes out below zero, and a simple ranking reads that as safer than owing nothing. In my screener, Bufetico, the debt layer stays gray when that happens, the way it does for Etsy.

Return on equity is profit divided by equity, and it goes wrong in a stranger way. Divide a loss by negative equity and you get a positive number. Take Spirit’s loss from March to December of 2025 and divide it by its equity at the end of the year. You get a big positive return on equity, for an airline that was four months from shutting down. Price to book, the share price divided by equity per share, breaks the same way.

A ratio can fool you when equity is above zero, too. Ford’s equity was $35,719 million at the end of June 2026, and about 85 percent of its debt belonged to Ford Credit, the lender inside Ford. Put all of Ford’s debt over that equity and you’re mixing a carmaker with a bank. I split the two apart in the Ford case.

When equity is negative, set those three ratios aside. Look at what paying the debt depends on: the cash the business brings in, whether its profit covers the interest, and when the debt comes due. I walked through that with Etsy and Starbucks.

Where this breaks

Reading those two lines only works if the company keeps the shares it buys back as treasury stock. Starbucks doesn’t. Its annual report says that under Washington state law, the shares it buys back are retired, so they’re canceled. Each share has a par value, a tiny face value. What Starbucks paid above it comes out of paid-in capital, the money shareholders put in, and out of retained earnings. That’s why Starbucks shows a retained deficit of $8,542.5 million at the end of June 2026, on a business that earned $1,856.4 million in fiscal 2025. On that line alone, it looks like Spirit.

Before you blame losses, read the equity note and the statement of equity. They show you where the buybacks went. The income statement shows whether there were any losses at all.

The last night at Spirit

Egan was at Spirit for about 23 years. Spirit came out of its first bankruptcy in March 2025, and the accounting rules for bankruptcy reset its books. It’s called fresh start accounting. Equity started over at $734.4 million, and retained earnings at zero. Right before the reset, retained earnings stood at minus $1,540.3 million. So the $2,832.7 million deficit at the end of 2025 is exactly Spirit’s loss from March 13 to December 31 of that year.

Key factsThe numbers and where they come from · 10 October 2026
  • At the end of 2025, Spirit Airlines had shareholders’ equity of minus $2,091.7 million and a retained deficit of $2,832.7 million, with no treasury stock, its last annual report shows.
  • McDonald’s ended 2025 with equity of minus $1,791 million, while its retained earnings were a positive $70,282 million and the shares it had bought back were carried at $79,316 million, its annual report shows.
  • Spirit stopped flying at 3 a.m. on May 2, 2026, after its bondholders said no to a bailout plan from the Trump administration, CNBC reported. The airline said about 17,000 people lost their jobs.
  • Under Washington state law, Starbucks retires the shares it buys back, its annual report says. Starbucks showed a retained deficit of $8,542.5 million at the end of June 2026, on a business that earned $1,856.4 million in fiscal 2025.

Sold too early, or held on too long?

Join the waitlist and I'll email you when Bufetico opens, plus a new article or tool now and then.

No more than one email a week. You can unsubscribe anytime, and the Privacy Policy explains how we handle your name and email.

Can't tell a cheap stock from a dying one?

The Bufetico Filter checks more than 30,000 companies against six layers and shows you only the ones that pass. You decide how strict each layer is. Bufetico opens soon.

Join the waitlist »